“…The lack of long time-series records at the provincial level does not currently allow an investigation of whether such a U-shaped trend is a part of a more wide N-shaped term or not, as found in other works (see for instance Holtz-Eakin and Selden, 1995). Unfortunately, the novelty of the analysis carried out in this article does not allow any comparison with former studies applied to the Italian case, which take into account different types of pollutants and/or make use of time series at the national level (Focacci, 2005;Sica, 2005;Cialani, 2007;Mazzanti et al, 2007Mazzanti et al, , 2008aMazzanti et al, , b, 2009aAcaravci and Ozturk, 2010;Iwata et al, 2011;Wang, 2012;Zanin and Marra, 2012).…”