Enhancing the Effects of Neurofeedback Training: The Motivational Value of the Reinforcers

Abstract

The brain activity that is measured by electroencephalography (EEG) can be modified through operant conditioning, specifically using neurofeedback (NF). NF has been applied to several disorders claiming that a change in the erratic brain activity would be accompanied by a reduction of the symptoms. However, the expected results are not always achieved. Some authors have suggested that the lack of an adequate response may be due to an incorrect application of the operant conditioning principles. A key factor in operant conditioning is the use of reinforcers and their value in modifying behavior, something that is not always sufficiently taken into account. This work aims to clarify the relevance of the motivational value versus the purely informational value of the reinforcer. In this study, 113 subjects were randomly assigned two different reinforcer conditions: a selected reinforcer—the subjects subjectively selected the reinforcers—or an imposed reinforcer—the reinforcers were assigned by the experimenter—and both groups undertook NF sessions to enhance the sensorimotor rhythm (SMR). In addition, the selected reinforcer group was divided into two subgroups: one receiving real NF and the other one sham NF. There were no significant differences between the groups at baseline in terms of SMR amplitude. After the intervention, only those subjects belonging to the selected reinforcer group and receiving real NF increased their SMR. Our results provide evidence for the importance of the motivational value of the reinforcer in Neurofeedback success.

Cardiac Diagnostic Feature and Demographic Identification (CDF-DI): An IoT Enabled Healthcare Framework Using Machine Learning

“…Scientific research uses a variety of performance matrices to assess prediction accuracy [ 60 , 61 , 62 ]. In binary classification problems, accuracy and F1-Score derived from Confusion matrics (CMs) have employed metrics for performance evaluation.…”

Exploring Inflammatory Status in Febrile Seizures Associated with Urinary Tract Infections: A Two-Step Cluster Approach

“…The neurofeedback approach, however, is a non-invasive approach based on operant conditioning [ 60 ]. While the EEG signal is recorded, its particular metrics to be trained (power, amplitude, frequency) are analyzed by the computer providing feedback in real-time to the subject [ 60 , 61 ]. As the signal is modulated toward the desired goal by comparison to the normative database embedded in the software, some “rewards” consisting of visual and/or auditory stimuli are offered to the trained subject.…”

Prior Prognostic Expectations as a Potential Predictor in Neurofeedback Training

“…Many neurofeedback studies assessed the effectiveness of neurofeedback training as a change in symptoms. However, the efficacy of neurofeedback training should be first assessed as an ability to produce changes in the EEG profile, and changes in symptoms or behavior should be considered a consequence of changes in the EEG profile (Pérez-Elvira et al, 2021). Although we applied a widely used protocol (beta/theta) for attentional enhancement, we did not account for the EGG profile of the group.…”

“…Feedback is the core component of such training, as the process reflects the principle of "no feedback, no learning." Operant conditioning is the basis of this learning process (Hammond, 2011;Pérez-Elvira et al, 2021), reinforcing or inhibiting learning by means of positive or negative feedback following an evaluation of the actions performed. Every neurofeedback training session follows a protocol that specifies the power of the frequency band to be trained and the area on the scalp where this power will be recorded.…”