Objective: To describe the effects of performance-enhancing supplements and caffeine on the blood pressure (BP) of an adolescent male. Case Summary: An adolescent male presented to his primary care provider for a preseason athletic physical. On physical exam, his BP was 162/90, exceeding the 99th percentile for his age. It had been elevated during the previous 2 yearly physicals. He was referred to the Pediatric Preventive Cardiology Clinic for follow-up. Illegal substance use and renal trauma were ruled out. During the evaluation, the patient acknowledged using energy drinks and performanceenhancing supplements, the majority of which were caffeine-based. His intention was to continue the use of supplements, so lisinopril was initiated. On follow-up, however, the patient reported supplement discontinuation, intermittent medication adherence, and lower home-based BP readings. He was subsequently lost to follow-up. An objective causality assessment revealed that the adverse drug event was probable. Discussion: When working with adolescent patients, it is particularly important to conduct an in-depth interview reflecting lifestyle choices. Use of performance-enhancing supplements and caffeine for adolescent athletes has been well reported in the literature. Adolescent use of supplements may be driven by misguided beliefs and lack of knowledge about potentially detrimental health effects, such as altered heart rate and elevated BP. Little evidence-based research is available to provide treatment guidance for clinicians regarding potential effects. Conclusions: A thorough patient history, including specific questions probing for any recent or chronic use of nutritional supplements, including energy drinks, will help identify substances that may contribute to BP variations. Even mild BP elevations in adolescents should lead clinicians to further investigate supplement use and include specific questions on any product use within the past 24 hours, several days, or longer. Adolescents may not consider the potential for adverse health effects when ingesting performance-enhancing supplements or energy drinks.