Evaluation and comparison of bioinformatic tools for the enrichment analysis of metabolomics data

Abstract

BackgroundBioinformatic tools for the enrichment of ‘omics’ datasets facilitate interpretation and understanding of data. To date few are suitable for metabolomics datasets. The main objective of this work is to give a critical overview, for the first time, of the performance of these tools. To that aim, datasets from metabolomic repositories were selected and enriched data were created. Both types of data were analysed with these tools and outputs were thoroughly examined.ResultsAn exploratory multivariate analysis of the most used tools for the enrichment of metabolite sets, based on a non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) of Jaccard’s distances, was performed and mirrored their diversity. Codes (identifiers) of the metabolites of the datasets were searched in different metabolite databases (HMDB, KEGG, PubChem, ChEBI, BioCyc/HumanCyc, LipidMAPS, ChemSpider, METLIN and Recon2). The databases that presented more identifiers of the metabolites of the dataset were PubChem, followed by METLIN and ChEBI. However, these databases had duplicated entries and might present false positives. The performance of over-representation analysis (ORA) tools, including BioCyc/HumanCyc, ConsensusPathDB, IMPaLA, MBRole, MetaboAnalyst, Metabox, MetExplore, MPEA, PathVisio and Reactome and the mapping tool KEGGREST, was examined. Results were mostly consistent among tools and between real and enriched data despite the variability of the tools. Nevertheless, a few controversial results such as differences in the total number of metabolites were also found. Disease-based enrichment analyses were also assessed, but they were not found to be accurate probably due to the fact that metabolite disease sets are not up-to-date and the difficulty of predicting diseases from a list of metabolites.ConclusionsWe have extensively reviewed the state-of-the-art of the available range of tools for metabolomic datasets, the completeness of metabolite databases, the performance of ORA methods and disease-based analyses. Despite the variability of the tools, they provided consistent results independent of their analytic approach. However, more work on the completeness of metabolite and pathway databases is required, which strongly affects the accuracy of enrichment analyses. Improvements will be translated into more accurate and global insights of the metabolome.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12859-017-2006-0) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Enabling tomography with low-cost C-arm systems

“…Regarding the reduced angular span and the difficulty of obtaining a high number of projections, our surface-constrained image reconstruction reduces significantly the streak artifacts derived from the low number of projections, similarly to previous proposals in the literature [ 23 – 25 ]. However, its main advantage over previous works is that the restriction on the search space by exploiting the surface-based support results in a complete recovery of the external contour of the sample and adjacent areas even for extremely reduced angular spans.…”

Chemical Characterization of Capsule-Brewed Espresso Coffee Aroma from the Most Widespread Italian Brands by HS-SPME/GC-MS

“…A variable with a VIP score greater than 1 can be considered significant/important in the model. Analysis was done using R (v3.6.1) and Metaboanalyst's output [33]. Model statistics were quantified based on the fraction of the sum of squares for the selected component (R 2 ), which equates to the percentage of the model variance explained, and the predictive ability (Q 2 ).…”

A fast adaptive algorithm for computing whole-genome homology maps

“…Thus, the final output of Mashmap2 and Minimap2 are alignment boundaries and scores, whereas Nucmer4 outputs base-to-base alignments. Both alignment-free methods Mashmap2 and Minimap2 are able to map most of the query bases to unique positions in all datasets (shown later), therefore base-to-base alignments can be computed quickly for the final output using chaining heuristics and vectorization techniques ( Suzuki and Kasahara, 2018 ; Li, 2018 ).…”