Exploring the utility of Bayesian Networks for modelling cultural ecosystem services: A canoeing case study

Abstract

Modelling cultural ecosystem services is challenging as they often involve subjective and intangible concepts. As a consequence they have been neglected in ecosystem service studies, something that needs remedying if environmental decision making is to be truly holistic. We suggest Bayesian Networks (BNs) have a number of qualities that may make them well-suited for dealing with cultural services. For example, they define relationships between variables probabilistically, enabling conceptual and physical variables to be linked, and therefore the numerical representation of stakeholder opinions. We assess whether BNs are a good method for modelling cultural services by building one collaboratively with canoeists to predict how the subjective concepts of fun and danger are impacted on by weir modification. The BN successfully captured the relationships between the variables, with model output being broadly consistent with verbal descriptions by the canoeists. There were however a number of discrepancies indicating imperfect knowledge capture. This is likely due to the structure of the network and the abstract and laborious nature of the probability elicitation stage. New techniques should be developed to increase the intuitiveness and efficiency of probability elicitation. The limitations we identified with BNs are avoided if their structure can be kept simple, and it is in such circumstances that BNs can offer a good method for modelling cultural ecosystem services.

Quantifying local ecosystem service outcomes by modelling their supply, demand and flow in Myanmar’s forest frontier landscape

“…In line with a previous review (Landuyt et al, 2013), we found the use of Bayesian networks highly suitable for modelling ES, particularly as our study is located in a data-scarce region (ibid) and involves different types of ES (Shaw et al, 2016). BN's probability distributions indicate to what extent certain ES can be enhanced, which can be a useful basis for designing targeted intervention strategies.…”

A Framework for Global Twenty-First Century Scenarios and Models of Biological Invasions

“…Especially, Bayesian modeling frameworks (e.g., Bayesian Network models) can account for highly heterogeneous sources of data and knowledge and significantly improve model accuracy (Ghazoul and McAllister 2003, Constantinou et al 2016). Such models have already been applied in other fields such as climate change (Reside et al 2018) and hydrology (Safavi et al 2015) or for modeling socioeconomic (Dawkins et al 2018) and cultural behavior (Shaw et al 2016). A recurrent adaptation and refinement of the models in conjunction with the development of more balanced storylines will ensure a consistent advancement of either of the two and contribute to the successful implementation of the biological invasion scenarios (see the core element of figure 1).…”

Importance of partial barriers and temporal variation in flow when modelling connectivity in fragmented river systems

“…The region's historical importance as a centre of metal working has resulted in the impoundment of the rivers by over 200 weirs (run-of-the-river low-head dams) which were mainly built to divert river water to water mills (Shaw, 2012). These structures are typically 1-3 m tall, with the incline of the downstream facing slope ranging from vertical to moderately steep (Shaw et al, 2016). By the 18th century impoundments and severe water pollution caused the extirpation of the formerly abundant salmon population (Firth, 1997).…”