The objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of diet starch concentration and fermentability (SF) fed during the early postpartum (PP) period on dry matter intake (DMI), yields of milk and milk components, body reserves, and metabolism. Fifty-two multiparous Holstein cows were used in a randomized block design with a 2 × 2 factorial arrangement of treatments. Treatment diets were formulated to 22% (LS) or 28% (HS) starch with dry ground corn (DGC) or high-moisture corn (HMC) as the primary starch source. Treatments were fed from 1 to 23 d PP and cows were switched to a common diet until 72 d PP to measure carryover (CO) effects. Treatment period (TP) diets were formulated for 22% forage neutral detergent fiber and 17% crude protein, and starch concentration was adjusted by substitution of corn grain for soyhulls. Throughout the experiment DMI and milk yield were measured daily, and milk components, body condition score (BCS), and body weight were measured weekly. Blood was collected weekly during the TP and every second week during the CO period. During the TP, HMC decreased DMI more when included in the HS (3.9 kg/d) than in the LS (0.9 kg/d) diets and HMC decreased yields of milk, fat, and FCM by 4.3, 0.19, and 4.8 kg/d, respectively. Treatments also interacted over time to decrease DMI and yields of milk and milk components more for HMC compared with DGC as time progressed during the TP. Loss of BCS was increased when HMC was fed in a HS diet (-0.38 vs. -0.17) and decreased when included in a LS diet (-0.21 vs. -0.29) with no effects on body weight change during the TP. Treatments interacted with time to affect plasma concentrations of glucose and insulin with HS increasing concentrations early in the TP compared with LS but with similar effects by the end of the TP. During the CO period, treatment effects on DMI diminished over time with no main effects of treatment for the entire period. Starch concentration and SF interacted to affect yields of milk, fat, and FCM during the CO period, which were greater for HS-DGC and LS-HMC (54.8 and 52.8, 1.76 and 1.81, and 51.3 and 52.2 kg/d, respectively) than for LS-DGC and HS-HMC (51.2 and 51.0, 1.68 and 1.64, and 48.4 and 48.6 kg/d, respectively). Treatments did not affect BCS change during the CO period but HS lost body weight compared with LS (-5.7 vs. 7.0 kg). Blood glucose and insulin concentrations were not affected by treatments during the CO period. Feeding a highly fermentable starch source during the early PP period decreased DMI and yields of milk and milk components compared with a less fermentable starch source and the depression in DMI was greater when fed in the higher starch diet. However, diet starch concentration had no effects on yield of milk or milk components.