Background: The insertion of the stapes piston into the vestibule provides the physical basis for a successful stapedotomy. In routine clinical practice, two different ways to handle prosthesis length are performed: (1) an individualized measurement of the stapes prosthesis length or (2) a standard prosthesis length for all cases. Objective: The objective of this study was to compare both ways of handling prosthesis length and the effect of these methods on insertional prosthesis depth. Material and Method: We retrospectively evaluated 39 patients after performing a stapedotomy for radiologically estimated vestibular stapes prosthesis insertion depth. The individual measured length data were hypothetically changed to a standard length of 4.75, 5, 5.25, and 5.5 mm, and the insertion depths were compared. Results: The individually measured prosthesis lengths led to an insertion depth between 0.2 and 1.6 mm (mean 0.74 mm). The ratio of insertion depth/vestibular depth was between 8 and 59.1% (mean 26.6%). The different assumed standard lengths led to different rates of the vestibulum positions and possible bony contacts at the vestibulum floor. Conclusion: The individual measurement led to a zero rate of the vestibulum positions of stapes prosthesis pistons with a low insertion depth/vestibular depth ratio.