Forced Termination of American Clergy: Its Effects and Connection to Negative Well-Being

Abstract

Forced termination of clergy involves constant negativity found in personal attacks and criticism from a small congregational faction. The minister feels psychologically pressured to step down from the ministry position and this process is often demeaning to the emotional and physical well-being of the minister. The prevalence of forced termination among clergy has ranged from 25% among many denominations to 41% among Assemblies of God ministers. Forced termination and its effects are serious problems that have yet to be adequately addressed by scholars in social science research. The lack of scholarly research in this area called for a large national study from a reputable research institution. This online study shows that 28% of ministers among 39 denominations experienced a forced termination. Forced termination was associated with high levels of depression, stress, and physical health problems. Forced termination was also associated with low levels of self-efficacy, and self-esteem.

Submission or Cooperation? Two Competing Approaches to Conflict Management in Mission Organizations

“…Such conflicts often slow down the work to which both parties feel called to (Dunaetz 2010a) and, even worse, may dishonor God who calls Christians to love one another as a sign of their discipleship (John 13:35) and who condemns fighting among Christians as a form of hatred toward him (James 4:1-10). It is a significant source of missionary attrition (Global Mapping International 2009) and may have long lasting negative consequences on a missionary's emotional health, physical health, and career (Tanner et al 2012a;Tanner et al 2012b;Romanov et al 1996).…”

Recovered Memories and Accusations of Sexual Abuse: A Review of Scientific Research Relevant to Missionary Contexts

“…When the innocent are falsely accused, even if no formal judgment is made against them, relationships may be broken and trust damaged. False accusations against full time Christian workers, especially those involved in cross cultural ministry, are particularly damaging (Tanner, Wherry, andAdams 2012).…”

Constructively Managing Program-related Conflict In Local Churches

“…However, tenure before resignation from such positions tends to be only a few years, often occurring in a context of conflict (Lawson, 1994). Such resignations, when forced, can have severe negative consequences on the life of the church staff member (Tanner, Wherry, & Zvonkovic, 2013;Tanner, Zvonkovic, & Adams, 2012).…”

“…The program's effectiveness may decrease and repercussions may be felt in other programs and among people not directly involved in the program where the conflict began. The consequences of such conflict can be devastating for the pastoral staff, individual members, and the church as a whole (Dunaetz, 2008;Gangel & Canine, 1992;Susek, 1999;Tanner, Zvonkovic, & Adams, 2012).…”