It takes an approximate 2-yr investment to raise a replacement heifer from birth to first calving, and selecting the most productive heifers earlier in life could reduce input costs. Daily milk consumption, serum total protein, pneumonia and scours incidences, body size composite, birth weights, and incremental body weights were collected on a commercial dairy farm from October 1, 2015, to January 1, 2019. Holstein calves (n = 5,180) were fed whole pasteurized nonsalable milk with a 30% protein and 5% fat enhancer added at 20 g/L of milk through an automated calf feeding system (feeders = 8) for 60 d on average. Calves were weighed at birth and several other times before calving. Average birth weight of calves was 40.6 ± 4.9 kg (mean ± standard deviation), serum total protein was 6.7 ± 0.63 mg/dL, and cumulative 60-d milk consumption was 508.1 ± 67.3 L with a range of 179.9 to 785.1 L. Daily body weights were predicted for individual animals using a third-order orthogonal polynomial to model body weight curves. The linear and quadratic effects of cumulative 60-d milk consumption, birth weight, feeder, year born, season born, respiratory incidence, scours incidence, and body size composite score were significant when predicting heifer body weight at 400 d (pBW 400 ) of age. There was up to a 263-kg difference in pBW 400 between the heaviest and lightest animal. Birth weight had a significant effect on predicted weights up to 400 d, and for every 1-kg increase in birth weight, there was a 2.5-kg increase in pBW 400 . Quadratic effect of cumulative 60-d milk consumption was significant up to 400 d. We divided 60-d milk consumption into quartiles, and heifers had the highest pBW 400 in the third quartile when 60-d consumption was between 507.8 and 552.5 L. Body size composite score showed a 21.5-kg difference in pBW 400 between the top and bottom 25th percentile of heifers. Heifers were 4.2 kg lighter at 400 d if treated for respiratory disease 3+ times during the first 60 d of life compared with heifers not treated for respiratory disease. Measurements that can be obtained in the early life of dairy calves continue to influence heifer growth up to 400 d of age.