The active site of the tyrosine family site-specific recombinase Flp contains a conserved catalytic pentad that includes two arginine residues, Arg-191 and Arg-308. Both arginines are essential for the transesterification steps of strand cleavage and strand joining in DNA substrates containing a phosphate group at the scissile position. During strand cleavage, the active site tyrosine supplies the nucleophile to form a covalent 3-phosphotyrosyl intermediate. The 5-hydroxyl group produced by cleavage provides the nucleophile to re-form a 3-5 phosphodiester bond in a recombinant DNA strand. In previous work we showed that substitution of the scissile phosphate (P) by the charge neutral methylphosphonate (MeP) makes Arg-308 dispensable during the catalytic activation of the MeP diester bond. However, in the Flp(R308A) reaction, water out-competes the tyrosine nucleophile (Tyr-343) to cause direct hydrolysis of the MeP diester bond. We now report that for MeP activation Arg-191 is also not required. In contrast to Flp(R308A), Flp(R191A) primarily mediates normal cleavage by Tyr-343 but also exhibits a weaker direct hydrolytic activity. The cleaved MeP-tyrosyl intermediate formed by Flp(R191A) can be targeted for nucleophilic attack by a 5-hydroxyl or water and channeled toward strand joining or hydrolysis, respectively. In collaboration with wild type Flp, Flp(R191A) promotes strand exchange between MeP-and P-DNA partners. Loss of a catalytically crucial positively charged side chain can thus be suppressed by a compensatory modification in the DNA substrate that neutralizes the negative charge on the scissile phosphate.The hallmark of the active sites of tyrosine site-specific recombinases and type IB topoisomerases is a catalytic pentad (Arg-Lys-(His/Lys)-Arg-(His/Trp)), with a tyrosine residue providing the nucleophile for DNA cleavage (1-6). The primary function of the conserved arginines Arg-191 and Arg-308 in Flp, inferred from crystallographic data, appears to be in balancing the phosphate negative charge in the transition state during the strand cleavage and strand joining steps of DNA recombination and relaxation, respectively. Replacement of alanine, glycine, or the conservative lysine at either of these positions results in the gross impairment of the catalytic activities of the corresponding Flp variants (7-10). Recent studies show that substitution of the scissile phosphate (P) 3 by methylphosphonate (MeP), which is charge neutral in the ground state and carries a nominal Ϫ1 charge in the transition state, makes Arg-308 dispensable in the MeP activation step by Flp (11). The same holds for the corresponding arginine residues of the Cre recombinase (Arg-292) and vaccinia topoisomerase (Arg-223) (12, 13). The chemical competence of Cre(R292A), Flp(R308A), and Topo(R223A) on their respective MeP substrates is consistent with the suspected electrophilic role of the positively charged arginine side chain in catalysis.Cre(R292A), wild type topoisomerase, and Topo(R223A) cleave the MeP diester bond using their ...