DNA strand exchange is the central process of homologous recombination. In budding yeast, this reaction is catalyzed by the recombinases Rad51 and Dmc1. Rad51 is responsible for recombinational repair of DNA damage during mitosis and is also important during meiotic recombination. Dmc1 is only expressed during meiosis and is required for meiotic recombination. The discovery that these two different recombinases are needed for normal levels of meiotic recombination in budding yeast raised the question of how the functions of these proteins relate to one another. The paper by Tsubouchi and Roeder (2006) in this issue of Genes & Development represents important progress toward what is apparently a rather complex answer. Tsubouchi and Roeder (2006) report discovery of a novel meiosis-specific protein, Hed1, which appears to inhibit Rad51 when Dmc1 is absent. The authors show mutation of the HED1 gene allows cells to bypass the meiotic arrest caused by a dmc1 mutation and resolve meiosis-specific double-strand breaks (DSBs) using Rad51. A hed1 mutation can also suppress the defects caused by mutation of HOP2, which codes for a Dmc1 accessory factor. Two-hybrid experiments show that Hed1 and Rad51 can interact directly and immuno-staining shows that subnuclear foci formed by Hed1 and Rad51 colocalize. Together these results imply that Hed1's influence on Rad51 activity is direct. Furthermore, expression of Hed1 in mitotic cells provided evidence that Hed1 expression can be sufficient to inhibit Rad51-dependent repair of mitotic DNA damage.A reasonable interpretation of these results is that the meiotic recombination machinery of budding yeast is regulated such that Dmc1 carries out most strand exchange. Tsubouchi and Roeder's (2006) results also add to evidence indicating that Rad51 is capable of replacing Dmc1's function under certain circumstances. Here, we place these new findings in the context of previous observations and present a model to explain how Rad51 and Dmc1 may cooperate to promote interhomolog recombination in budding yeast, while at the same time accounting for the observed functional redundancy. We further speculate as to how the functional relationship of Rad51 and Dmc1 may have evolved.The notion that Rad51 activity is blocked during meiosis is not new. Previous work showed that Dmc1-independent recombination is inhibited by proteins associated with axial elements (Schwacha and Kleckner 1997;Xu et al. 1997;Bishop et al. 1999;Niu et al. 2005) proteinaceous structures that organize pairs of sister chromatids into two parallel sets of loops by binding at their base. The assembly of the synaptonemal complex brings an axial element with its pair of sisters into close parallel alignment with another axial element holding the homologous sister pair. Three interacting axis-associated proteins-Red1, Hop1, and Mek1-regulate recombination by suppressing Dmc1-independent recombination and, in the case of Red1 and Hop1, by enhancing the efficiency of DSB formation in a locus-specific manner (Rockmill and Roeder...