Influence of the Kinaesthetics care conception during patient handling on the development of musculoskeletal complaints and diseases – A scoping review

Abstract

The Kinaesthetics care conception is a nursing approach for patient handling which aims to prevent work-related complaints and diseases. The evidence about the influence of Kinaesthetics on musculoskeletal disorders among persons who handle patients is unclear to date. The purposes of the scoping review are to gain insight into the current state of research regarding the clinical effectiveness of Kinaesthetics (in terms of perceived exertion and musculoskeletal complaints) among persons who handle patients and to identify potential research gaps. A scoping review was conducted. The search strategy comprised a systematic search in electronic databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, AMED, CINAHL), a hand search, a fast forward search (Web of Science) and a Google scholar-search. The review process was carried out independently by two reviewers. Methodological quality was assessed for all studies using three methodological main categories (reporting quality, internal validity, external validity). Thirteen studies with different study designs were included. Seven studies investigated musculoskeletal complaints and nine studies the perceived exertion of nursing staff. Most studies were of very low methodology. Most studies reported a decrease of musculoskeletal complaints and perceived exertion due to Kinaesthetics. In conclusion, there is only little evidence of very low quality about the effectiveness of Kinaesthetics. Out of the studies it could be assumed that Kinaesthetics may decrease the patient handling related perceived exertion and musculoskeletal pain of persons who handle patients. But an overestimation of these results is likely, due to inadequate methodology of included studies. As a result, no clear recommendations about the effectiveness of the Kinaesthetics care conception can be made yet. Since a research gap was shown, further high quality intervention studies are necessary for clarifying the effectiveness of Kinaesthetics.PROSPERO registry numberCRD42015015811

Evidence of Workplace Interventions—A Systematic Review of Systematic Reviews

“…23 reviews on workplace interventions for the prevention and improvement of musculoskeletal disorders were identified [3,5,8,9,10,11,34,58,59,60,61,62,63,64,65,66,67,68,69,70,71,72,73]. In these reviews, 407 individual studies were summarized, predominantly evaluating behavioral preventive interventions, such as training and education, exercise programs, and ergonomic interventions.…”

“…Improving working conditions may promote physical and mental health by combining both the individual and organizational level. A number of reviews and single studies have addressed the efficacy and cost-effectiveness of well-designed worksite health promotion programs to improve the health of employees and save money for employers [2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13].…”

STAR-VITAL, a Four Year Comprehensive Workplace Health Promotion Program: Study Design

“…It is interesting that despite many positive effects perceived from other WHPPs, participation rates are critically low [25,26]. WHPPs have positive effects on employee behaviours (in terms of encouraging regular physical activity, healthy eating, stress management, sleep hygiene, and healthy relationships) which increase personal resiliency and improve health [19,[29][30][31][32][33][34][35][36][37][38][39][40][41][42][43][44]. The potential strength of the STAR-VITAL program is that it addresses multiple variables in the work environment (work-related health risks) and behavioural habits (physical activity and eating habits) of employees in SMEs.…”

Classification Of Body Postures Using Smart Workwear

“…A technology-supported measurement system could therefore help to improve the situation. In addition to the validity of the measurement, a particular [1] One meta-study showed zero to only small effects [14], although few controlled studies show effects for single body regions or specific training approaches [15,16]. challenge is the special requirements placed on the measurement system in everyday working life.…”