Influence of the maintenance in seismic response of Lorca historic centre masonry residential buildings after the 11 May 2011 earthquake

Abstract

Lorca, the city centre of which had been one of the first in Spain to be declared an artistic historic site (1964), is an earthquake prone city. This is the reason why its unreinforced masonry vernacular residential architecture includes reinforcement features (quoins, pegs or ring beams) reducing the seismic vulnerability and improving, consequently, their seismic behaviour. Nevertheless, the seismic response of those buildings to the Lorca May 11th 2011 earthquake was very heterogeneous; it is important to point out that even some of them were demolished in the aftermath of this event. Given that the seismicity and construction and geometric characteristics (load-bearing walls, floors, materials, height, façade layout, etc.) are similar in the historic centre, a comparative study of the vulnerability of a sample of buildings with diverse observed damage degrees has been carried out in order to understand why their seismic response has been different. Results showed that notwithstanding the influence of construction techniques, the level of building maintenance (masonry and roofs) is a determinant factor in lowering the vulnerability of unreinforced masonry structures in historic city centres and in improving their seismic behaviour.

Mapping an Urban City Centre for Seismic Risk Assessment: Application to Valencia (Spain)

“…-Despite the influence of the construction techniques, the state of preservation is a determinant factor in the buildings seismic performance, especially in the case of unreinforced masonry (URM) buildings, not only for the building itself, but also due to the lack of the stabilizing contribution of neighbouring cells when the maintenance level is bad or the building is ruined (Carocci, Lagomarsino, 2009;Basset-Salom, Guardiola-Víllora, 2013;Guardiola-Víllora, Basset-Salom, 2019). Figure 3 shows buildings of the same typology but with different state of preservation.…”