‘Just Google It?’: Pupils’ Perceptions and Experience of Research in the Secondary Classroom

Abstract

While numerous studies examine perceptions of research held by university researchers, studies examining perceptions held by school pupils are rare. To address this gap and following analysis of questionnaire data (N = 2634, KS3/4/5 pupils), we conducted 11 group interviews with 100 pupils in England to investigate their experiences of research during schooling and their perceptions of how research is conceived, conducted and where its utility and significance lie. Thematic analysis of the interview data – informed by Angela Brew’s 4-tier descriptor of perceptions of research (domino, trading, layer, journey), Jenni Stubb's and colleagues' elaboration of this descriptor, Jan Meyer's and colleagues' conceptions of research inventory (CoRI) and Diane Bills’ distinction between Research and research – led to seven themes. Here we elaborate the most significant of these themes: fact finding as research; who formulates and owns a research question; and the friction between uninformed opinion and informed view. We conclude that secondary pupils’ experiences and perceptions of research, while overall relatively rich, vary across different disciplines. We also conclude that pupils would benefit substantially from more comprehensive engagement with research processes, and we observe the role that qualifications such as the Extended Project Qualification can play in fostering said engagement

Research skills in medical education

“…Most of our medical students are high-achievers, previously attaining high grades by learning and recalling facts. A UK study found that whilst school pupils are generally familiar with the idea of research, for example in forming hypotheses, they have few opportunities to test their own research questions (Yeoman et al, 2017). Whilst considering this evidence, it is also important to note that many of our students in the UK are now graduates, coming from a first degree where they are likely to have been exposed to research experience.…”

Going beyond the one-off: How can STEM engagement programmes with young people have real lasting impact?

“…Finally, a number of protracted programmes for secondary and sixth-form students to experience undertaking cutting-edge scientific research have emerged in recent years. These have the potential to address the disconnect between science education and what professional scientists actually do (Braund and Reiss, 2006;Yeoman et al, 2017), which may have a role to play in raising, maintaining or confirming students' aspirations towards STEM subjects (L. . Unfortunately, such programmes are rare globally, with those that do exist often lacking active support from researchers and/or targeting of disadvantaged groups (Bennett et al, 2018;M.O.…”

Transforming school students' aspirations into destinations through extended interaction with cutting-edge research: Physics Research in School Environments

“…However, exactly how this science is conducted is not often well understood outside of academia, particularly at school-level due to the lack of research methods within current science teaching (e.g. Hodson, 1998;Braund and Reiss, 2006;Yeoman et al, 2017). Currently four projects have been developd for the PRiSE programme at QMUL, which we briefly summarise here indicating key project personnel (referring to the roles mentioned previously).…”