Konstruksi Identitas Kolektif Warga Desa Adat dalam Gerakan Tolak Reklamasi Teluk Benoa di Bali

Wiranata, I Made Anom; Siahaan, Hotman

doi:10.24843/jkb.2019.v09.i02.p07

Cited by 4 publications

(9 citation statements)

References 9 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Yet, the proposed reclamation of Bali's Benoa Bay provoked such a movement. In the case of Bali, the opposition invoked a “pan‐Balinese” identity to mobilize massive, recurring protests against reclamation (Wiranata & Siahaan, 2019). The movement's identity was pan‐Balinese in the sense that it purported to encompass the entire island, and that it drew on religious, cultural, and institutional features common throughout Balinese society.…”

Section: Reclamation and The Puzzle Of Balinese Identitymentioning

confidence: 99%

“…These youth councils organized demonstrations, hung banners, and otherwise lobbied their neighbors, elders, and families to speak out against reclamation (Bräuchler, 2018). Yet, while many village leaders privately sympathized with the demands of the youth councils, they were reluctant to issue public pronouncements on matters beyond the scope of customary affairs (Wiranata & Siahaan, 2019).…”

Section: Evolution Of a Movementmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…Wiranata and Siahaan (2019), in a fascinating article, explain why the list of sacred sites was so decisive in the effort to mobilize customary villages against reclamation. The authors report that I Wayan Swarsa, the customary village head of Kuta, personally opposed reclamation, but that the customary village council could not act against reclamation without a justification based on Balinese culture or the Hindu religion.…”

Section: Evolution Of a Movementmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…Initially, the protests expressed the parochial interests of specific groups and decried the local effects on southern Bali. The massive protests of 2016, by contrast, articulated a “pan‐Balinese” identity (Wiranata & Siahaan, 2019). These demonstrators framed opposition to the project as a religious and cultural obligation of customary society, and invoked Bali's anticolonial wars of puputan , or resistance “to the end” (Dewi, 2015).…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

See 3 more Smart Citations

Coastal reclamation and Balinese identity

Tans

2021

Asian Politics and Policy

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The proposed reclamation of Benoa Bay triggered huge demonstrations that rejected the project in the name of Balinese identity. Yet, the politicization of identity seems ill‐suited to an anti‐reclamation movement, because the location‐specific costs of reclamation encourage local, not regional, resistance. The politicization of identity likewise has few precedents in Bali's own history, where politics usually revolves around class, caste, and region. This article explains this divergent outcome with reference to the specific social and institutional context of opposition to reclamation. Specifically, the anti‐reclamation movement embraced Balinese identity as a motivating principle because identity provided the only means to mobilize cross‐class protests large enough to block the project. Using the Bali Post archive and primary sources, the article shows that leaders of the opposition constructed reclamation as a threat to Balinese identity only after parochial, region‐specific efforts failed to block the project.

show abstract

Section: Reclamation and The Puzzle Of Balinese Identitymentioning

confidence: 99%

Section: Evolution Of a Movementmentioning

confidence: 99%

Section: Evolution Of a Movementmentioning

confidence: 99%

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

See 2 more Smart Citations

Coastal reclamation and Balinese identity

Tans

2021

Asian Politics and Policy

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Pergerakan demontrasi dan unjuk rasa tolak reklamasi teluk Benoa kerap kali menjadi kegiatan rutin bagi anggota Dalmas polri dalam memberikan pengamanan (Wiranata & Siahaan, 2019). Pelaksanaan demontrasi teluk benoa yang di mulai sejak tahun 2012 hingga 2018 umumnya berjalan dengan aman serta jauh dari kata anarkis.…”

Section: Pendahuluanunclassified

Peran Anggota Kepolisian Dalmas Polda Bali dalam Penegakan Hukum terhadap Penanganan Unjuk Rasa Tolak Reklamasi Teluk Benoa

Putra¹,

Widiati

Sugiartha

2020

JKH

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Every citizen has the right to express an opinion in accordance with Law Number 9 of 1998 concerning Freedom of Expressing Opinions in Public. Freedom of opinion is generally carried out by demonstrations. The recent demonstration in Bali is a demonstration against the reclamation of Benoa Bay. This is of particular concern to members of the Bali Police Dalmas as the main party in the handling of this demonstration. In handling it, the Bali Police Dalmas is guided to enforce the law against each of these demonstrations. Based on this background, this research was conducted with the aim of describing how the role of members of the Bali Police Dalmas police in law enforcement against the Benoa Bay protest against the Benoa Bay reclamation and what factors hindered the implementation of handling the Benoa Bay reclamation protest action by members of the Bali Police Dalmas. This study used an empirical legal research method. The results of this study indicated that the role of the Bali Police Dalmas in enforcing the law against the protest against Benoa Bay reclamation was carried out based on pre-emptive, preventive, and repressive actions based on statutory regulations and the police chief regulations regarding the handling of demonstrations. In addition, the factors that hindered the implementation of the protest against the reclamation of Benoa Bay by members of the Bali Police Dalmas include internal and external factors. the internal factor is factor of Dalmas members themselves, both from a mental perspective, professionalism, and knowledge about how to handle protests. Meanwhile, the external factor is generally the mass of protesters who do not understand the provisions that apply to the implementation of a demonstration.

show abstract

Relasi Kekuasaan antar Pemerintah, Masyarakat & LSM pada Revitalisasi Teluk Jakarta

Gugat

Abubakar

Susanti

2022

IJD

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The purpose of this study is to analyze the power relations between the government, society and non-governmental organizations in the revitalization of Jakarta Bay. This research uses qualitative research with a case study approach. The research location is in the province of Jakarta with a focus on the revitalization area of Jakarta Bay. The power relations formed in the revitalization of the Gulf divide the power relations into three parts that influence each other, namely: a) The place or arena of power is at the local level; b) The power of each stakeholder is different, visible power works between the government and the community as well as NGOs and relations between communities and NGOs in the planning process to implementation, then the hidden power that the government has over the community is formed so that an agenda setting is formed by the government towards policy implemented in the Gulf; and c) Place or space in power that was formed in the planning process to the implementation that was created, namely the invited space carried out by the government for the community and NGOs in the planning process for the revitalization of Jakarta Bay.Keyword: Stakeholder, Power Relation, Politic SpaceAbstrakTujuan penelitian ini adalah untuk menganalisis relasi kekuasaan antar pemerintah, masyarkat dan Lembaga Swadaya Masyarakat pada revitalisasi teluk Jakarta. Penelitian ini menggunkaan jenis penelitian kualitatif dengan pendekatan studi kasus. Lokasi penelitian berada di provinsi Jakarta dengan fokus pada kawasan revitalisasi Teluk Jakarta. Relasi kekuasaan yang terbentuk dalam revitalisasi Teluk membagi relasi kekuasaan menjadi tiga bagian yang saling mempengaruhi, yaitu: a) Place atau arena kekuasaan berada pada tingkat local; b) Power yang dimiliki masing-masing stakeholder berbeda, bekerjanya visible power antar pemerintah dengan masyarakat maupu NGO dan relasi antar masyarakat dan NGO dalam proses perencanaan hingga implementasinya, kemudian bekerja hidden power yang dimiliki pemerintah terhadap masyarakat sehingga terbentuk suatu strategi agenda oleh pemerintah terhadap kebijakan yang diterapkan di Teluk; dan c) Place atau ruang dalam kekuasaan yang terbentuk dalam proses perencanaan hingga implementasi yang tercipta yaitu invited space yang dilakukan pemerintah terhadap masayrakat dan NGO dalam proses perencanaan revitalisasi Teluk Jakarta.Kata Kunci : Stakeholder, Relasi Kekuasaan, Ruang Politik.

show abstract

Konstruksi Identitas Kolektif Warga Desa Adat dalam Gerakan Tolak Reklamasi Teluk Benoa di Bali

Cited by 4 publications

References 9 publications

Coastal reclamation and Balinese identity

Coastal reclamation and Balinese identity

Peran Anggota Kepolisian Dalmas Polda Bali dalam Penegakan Hukum terhadap Penanganan Unjuk Rasa Tolak Reklamasi Teluk Benoa

Relasi Kekuasaan antar Pemerintah, Masyarakat & LSM pada Revitalisasi Teluk Jakarta

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About