“…Like any ancient 3-dimensional solution to the Ricci flow, h(s) has non-negative sectional curvature ([9], 6.50 and [7]), while on the other hand (18) implies that for all r > 0, vol h(0) B 0 (x, r) ≥ vr 3 , that is to say that the Asymptotic Volume Ratio (AVR, see note page 7) of h(0) is strictly positive. According to Perelman ([11], 11.4), the only possibility is that (M, h(s)) is the trivial static solution given by the Euclidian metric (R 3 , g E 3 ).…”