The origin of the recently discovered Flatreef remains debated due to the pronounced interaction of the magmatic rocks with sedimentary floor rocks, resulting in a complex intrusive stratigraphy. In this study, we report new Nd isotopic compositions of Flatreef lithologies intersected by borehole UMT-393 on the farm Macalacaskop in order to improve our understanding of the magmatic history of the deposit and to further test the putative correlation between the Flatreef/Platreef and the Upper Critical Zone of the remainder of the Bushveld Complex. The initial epsilon Nd (εNdi) values for the Flatreef range between −5.2 and −7.6, overlapping with εNdi values of the Upper Critical Zone from the eastern (ranging between − 4.8 and − 8.5) and the Upper Critical Zone and Main Zone from the western limb (−6.3 and −7.6, and −6.3 and −7.4 respectively) of the Bushveld Complex. The Flatreef εNdi values also overlap with those of the Platreef; however, due to the varying footwall lithologies of the Platreef along strike, Platreef rocks display a wider variation in isotopic composition. Our findings support the correlation of the Flatreef with the Upper Critical Zone — Main Zone transition interval in the remainder of the Bushveld Complex, which includes the Merensky and Bastard reefs. Due to significant overlap between the εNdi values of the Flatreef and local potential contaminants occurring at the base of the Northern Limb, we propose that the Sr–Nd isotopic composition of the magmas that gave rise to the Flatreef are most likely attributable to the interaction of mantle-derived magma with upper and lower crustal rocks of the Kaapvaal Craton within a sub-Bushveld staging chamber, with possible syn- to post-emplacement modification as a result of interaction with dolomitic footwall rocks.