Measuring the competition and banking efficiency level: a study at four commercial banks in Indonesia

Abstract

The banking sector plays a vital role in the economy of each country. Banks are required to operate in a sound, efficient, and reliable manner in order to stimulate economic growth. To achieve that, a basic framework for the Indonesian banking system has been developed, known as the Indonesian Banking Architecture (IBA) aimed at strengthening the structure and enhancing the competitiveness of the banking industry. This study aimed to analyze the level of competition, the ability, and influence of the competition on banks efficiency, so banks can maintain the performance level and provide economic growth. This study used a quantitative approach with a panel regression analysis model. The results have shown that the banking industry in Indonesia tends to be monopolistic. The character of many sellers, differentiated products, sellers freely entering and leaving the market, as well as the presence of advertisement and product quality competitions were examined. Bank competition that leads to a monopolistic market structure stimulated banks to achieve higher profits and put bank projects and financing at high risk. Competition had a negative correlation with bank efficiency because competition encourages banks to focus on profit rather than efficiency, engage in risky financing/projects, and undertake high lending activities. Moreover, four big banks in Indonesia are in the “too big to fail” position. Banking regulators in Indonesia must maintain and produce reliable and stable banks to compete globally. AcknowledgementThe authors would like to thank all those who have contributed to the completion of this article, especially the leadership of the Department of Economics and the Faculty of Economics and Business, Brawijaya University, who provided facilitation for publication in reputable international journals.

The Cost Efficiency and Competition Relationship: Evidence from Saudi Arabian Banks and Non-Structural Approaches to Analysis

“…Based on the generalized method of moments (GMM) system, the results showed that competition positively affects the cost efficiency and stability of the banks. Wahyudi et al (2021) applied a quantitative approach, along with a panel regression analysis model, to measure the levels of competition and banking efficiency within Indonesia. The results revealed a negative correlation between competition and bank efficiency because competition motivates banks to concentrate on profits rather than efficiency, engage in riskier financing projects, and undertake high-lending activities.…”

“…Therefore, the relationship between banks' cost efficiency and competition exhibits mixed evidence in the literature, as, in some cases, banks' regulators deregulate and liberalize banks, with the result of reduced cost inefficiency (Wahyudi et al 2021;Apergis and Polemis 2016). During the financial crisis of 2008, the relationship between efficiency and competition became more complex (Apergis and Polemis 2016).…”

The impact of banking sector development on economic growth: Comparative analysis of Ukraine and some EU countries

“…Considering that the methodological framework of this study consists of two consecutive but interconnected blocks, it is based on the generalization of scientific publications, which relate, firstly, to the identification of factors and conditions, methodological approaches to assessing the banking sector development, its impact on social and economic development; secondly, to the methods, directions, tools and means of state policy for the formation and realization of financial instruments for realizing the banking sector's potential in stimulating sustainable development of the country. This required taking into account the research results, substantiating the indicators and methods of analyzing the parameters of the efficiency of the financial system, including its banking sector, especially organizational development (Chanderjeet, 2017), the level of losses (Hashim & O'Hanlon, 2016), bank liquidity (Munteanu, 2012), social responsibility of the financial and credit system (Revelli & Viviani, 2015), efficiency and reliability of banking activity (Schaeck & Čihák, 2008), competitiveness of the banking system (Wahyudi et al, 2021), the profitability of financial sector entities (Yuksel et al, 2018). Assessments made based on the criterion of "compliance with the standards and quality requirements of financial management by the subjects of the banking sector in the country" are endowed with a similar character.…”

Impact of Changes in Macroeconomic Indicators on Banking Indicators in Ukraine

“…For example, Wahyudi S., T., Nabella R. S., and Sari K. conducted a study of the relationship between competition and the efficiency of the banking sector in Indonesia, which led to the conclusion that bank competition that leads to a monopolistic market structure stimulated banks to achieve higher profits and put bank projects and financing at high risk. Competition has had a negative correlation with bank efficiency because competition encourages banks to focus on profit rather than efficiency, engage in risky financing/projects, and undertake high lending activities (Setyo Tri Wahyudi, Rihana Sofie Nabella and Kartika Sari, 2021). Nguhen Phu Ha in his article "Impact of macroeconomic factors and interaction with institutional performance on Vietnamese bank share prices''.…”