2Mitochondria rely on cellular machinery for their division, which is an essential component of metabolic response of the cell. Many division factors have been identified; however, a framework accounting for the energetic requirements of the mitochondrial fission process is lacking. We report that the presence of an active constriction does not ensure fission. Instead, by measuring constrictions down to ~100 nm with time-lapse super-resolution microscopy, we found that 34% of constrictions failed to divide and 'reversed' to an unconstricted state. Higher local curvaturesreflecting an increased bending energy -made constriction sites more likely to divide, but often with a significant residual energy barrier to fission. Our data suggest that membrane tension, largely arising from pulling forces, could account for this missing energy. These results lead us to propose that mitochondrial fission is probabilistic, and can be modeled as arising from bending energy complemented by a fluctuating membrane tension.Mitochondria are highly dynamic organelles, transported through the cytoplasm along cytoskeletal networks as they change in size and shape. Mitochondrial morphologies can range from a filamentous, connected network to a fragmented collection of individuals. Underlying such morphological changes are altered equilibria between fusion and division 1,2 . These transformations have been linked to an adaptive response to cellular energy requirements, for example in response to stress [3][4][5] or the cell cycle 6 . As a vestige of their bacterial origins, mitochondria cannot be generated de novo, but must multiply by division, or fission, of existing mitochondria 7 . Division has also been suggested to act as part of a quality control mechanism 8,9 and an intracellular signal for mitophagy 10,11 .All rights reserved. No reuse allowed without permission.(which was not peer-reviewed) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity.The copyright holder for this preprint . http://dx.doi.org/10.1101/255356 doi: bioRxiv preprint first posted online 3 In bacterial division systems, internal assembly of the fission machinery is tightly regulated and a series of cell cycle checkpoints ensure daughter cell viability. In contrast, the mitochondrial division machinery is external to the organelle, allowing cells to flexibly regulate fission. Initially, the division site is marked by a pre-constriction defined by contact with ER tubules 12 and deformed by targeted actin polymerization [13][14][15] Live-cell Structured Illumination Microscopy (SIM) of Drp1-mediated mitochondrial constriction events enabled us to measure dynamic changes in membrane geometry leading up to and following division. We discovered that a fraction of mitochondria constrict dramatically before relaxing to an unconstricted state, termed 'reversals'. Using a custom-written image analysis package and classical elasticity theory, we calculated the energy differences between fission and reversal events, which al...