Succeeding in the
substitution of pharmaceutical compounds with
ions deliverable with the use of resorbable biomaterials could have
far-reaching benefits for medicine and economy. Calcium phosphates
are known as excellent accommodators of foreign ions. Manganese, the
fifth most abundant metal on Earth was studied here as an ionic dopant
in β-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP) ceramics. β-TCP
containing different amounts of Mn2+ ions per Mn
x
Ca3–x
(PO4)2 formula (x = 0, 0.001, 0.01, and 0.1)
was investigated for a range of physicochemical and biological properties.
The results suggested the role of Mn2+ as a structure booster,
not breaker. Mn2+ ions increased the size of coherent X-ray
scattering regions averaged across all crystallographic directions
and also lowered the temperature of transformation of the hydroxyapatite
precursor to β-TCP. The particle size increased fivefold, from
20 to 100 nm, in the 650–750 °C region, indicating that
the reaction of formation of β-TCP was accompanied by a considerable
degree of grain growth. The splitting of the antisymmetric stretching
mode of the phosphate tetrahedron occurred proportionally to the Mn2+ content in the material, while electron paramagnetic resonance
spectra suggested that Mn2+ might substitute for three
out of five possible calcium ion positions in the unit cell of β-TCP.
The biological effects of Mn-free β-TCP and Mn-doped β-TCP
were selective: moderately proliferative to mammalian cells, moderately
inhibitory to bacteria, and insignificant to fungi. Unlike pure β-TCP,
β-TCP doped with the highest concentration of Mn2+ ions significantly inhibited the growth of all bacterial species
tested: Staphylococcus aureus, Salmonella typhi, Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Enterococcus faecalis. The overall effect against
the Gram-positive bacteria was more intense than against the Gram-negative
microorganisms. Meanwhile, β-TCP alone had an augmentative effect
of the viability of adipose-derived mesenchymal stem cells (ADMSCs)
and the addition of Mn2+ tended to reduce the extent of
this augmentative effect, but without imparting any toxicity. For
all Mn-doped β-TCP concentrations except the highest, the cell
viability after 72 h incubation was significantly higher than that
of the negative control. Assays evaluating the effect of Mn2+-containing β-TCP formulations on the differentiation of ADMSCs
into three different lineagesosteogenic, adipogenic, and chondrogenicdemonstrated
no inhibitory or adverse effects compared to pure β-TCP and
powder-free positive controls. Still, β-TCP delivering the lowest
amount of Mn2+ seemed most effective in sustaining the
differentiation process toward all three phenotypes, indicating that
the dose of Mn2+ in β-TCP need not be excessive to
be effective.