Currently, there are a lack of FDA-approved tocolytics for the management of preterm labor. We previously observed that the isoflavones mundulone and mundulone acetate (MA) inhibit intracellular Ca2+-regulated myometrial contractility. Here, we further probed the potential of these natural products to be small molecule leads for discovery of novel tocolytics by: (1) examining uterine-selectivity by comparing concentration-response between human primary myometrial cells and a major off-target site, aortic vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs), (2) identifying synergistic combinations with current clinical tocolytics to increase efficacy or and reduce off-target side effects, (3) determining cytotoxic effects and (4) investigating the efficacy, potency and tissue-selectivity between myometrial contractility and constriction of fetal ductus arteriosus (DA), a major off-target of current tocolytics. Mundulone displayed significantly greater efficacy (Emax = 80.5% vs. 44.5%, p=0.0005) and potency (IC50 = 27 μM and 14 μM, p=0.007) compared to MA in the inhibition of intracellular-Ca2+ from myometrial cells. MA showed greater uterine-selectivity, compared to mundulone, based on greater differences in the IC50 (4.3 vs. 2.3 fold) and Emax (70% vs. 0%) between myometrial cells compared to aorta VSMCs. Moreover, MA demonstrated a favorable in vitro therapeutic index of 8.8, compared to TI = 0.8 of mundulone, due to its significantly (p<0.0005) smaller effect on the viability of myometrial (hTERT-HM), liver (HepG2) and kidney (RPTEC) cells. However, mundulone exhibited synergism with two current tocolytics (atosiban and nifedipine), while MA only displayed synergistic efficacy with only nifedipine. Of these synergistic combinations, only mundulone + atosiban demonstrated a favorable TI = 10 compared to TI=0.8 for mundulone alone. While only mundulone showed concentration-dependent inhibition of ex vivo mouse myometrial contractions, neither mundulone or MA affected mouse fetal DA vasoreactivity. The combination of mundulone and atosiban yielded greater tocolytic efficacy and potency on term pregnant mouse and human myometrial tissue compared to single-drugs. Collectively, these data highlight the difference in uterine‐selectivity of Ca2+‐mobilization, effects on cell viability and tocolytic efficacy between mundulone and MA. These natural products could benefit from medicinal chemistry efforts to study the structural activity relationship for further development into a promising single- and/or combination-tocolytic therapy for management of preterm labor.