“…Several studies (32%) provided no programmed consequences for responding (e.g., Azrin, 1958;Flanagan et al, 1958;Maltzman, Holz, & Kunze, 1965), or paid subjects an hourly rate that was independent of performance (e.g., Weiner, 1962Weiner, , 1963Weiner, , 1964a. A few studies (12%) used other positive reinforcers such as tokens exchangeable for privileges (Ayllon & Azrin, 1966), cigarettes (Herman & Azrin, 1964;Miller, 1970), and M&M's (Romanczyk, 1976).…”