“…However, the impact of biochar on the soil physical and biological properties has been mixed. For example, Chintala et al (2014b) reported that biochar reduced CO 2 emission, whereas Fernández et al (2014) and Wang et al (2012a) reported that biochar did not infl uence or increased emission. Mixed results could be attributed to biochar having diff erent impacts on diff erent components of the N cycle, and that GHG emissions are impacted by the process used to produce biochar (Singh et al, 2010;Castaldi et al, 2011;Wang et al, 2011Wang et al, , 2012aWang et al, , 2012bZimmerman et al, 2011;Zhang et al, 2012;Case et al, 2012;Kammann et al, 2012;Cayuela et al, 2013;Clough et al, 2013;Biederman and Harpole, 2012;Chintala et al, 2014aChintala et al, , 2014cFernández et al, 2014;Song et al, 2014;Prommer et al, 2014;Creamer et al, 2014;Nelissen et al, 2014;Mollinedo et al, 2015).…”