Motivational Strategies, Working Alliance, and Protherapeutic Behaviors in Batterer Intervention Programs: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Abstract

Motivational strategies are among the most promising approaches to improve the effectiveness of batterer intervention programs (BIPs). An individualized motivational plan (IMP) is one of these motivational strategies. The present study aimed to explore whether adding an IMP to a standard BIP improved the participant-facilitator working alliance and participants' protherapeutic behaviors. To this end a randomized controlled trial was conducted. One hundred fifty-three men convicted of intimate partner violence were randomly assigned to either a standard BIP (control condition, n = 79) or a standard BIP plus IMP (experimental condition, n = 74). Working alliance (i.e., general working alliance, agreement, and bond) was assessed with the Working Alliance Inventory-Observer, short version. Protherapeutic behaviors (i.e., assumption of responsibility, participant role behavior, and group value) were assessed with the Observational Coding of Protherapeutic Group Behavior. Both working alliance and protherapeutic behaviors were assessed by an external observer early and late in intervention. Our results showed that both general working alliance and agreement and bond, were significantly higher in the standard BIP plus IMP intervention condition, both early and late in intervention. All protherapeutic behaviors were significantly higher in the standard BIP plus IMP early in intervention, and also late in intervention for assumption of responsibility and group value. Our findings have important practical implications as our results clearly showed that a motivational strategy tool such as the IMP improves key intervention processes (i.e., working alliance and protherapeutic behaviors) in BIPs, therefore increasing their effectiveness. Palabras clave: Programas de intervención con maltratadores Estrategias motivacionales Alianza de trabajo Conductas proterapéuticas Ensayo clínico aleatorizado

Psychotherapist’s persuasiveness in anxiety: Scale development and relation to the working alliance.

“…Intraclass correlation coefficients estimates, and their 95% confident intervals, were based on a mean-rating (k = 2), absolute agreement, 2-way random-effects model (Koo & Li, 2016). The scale’s internal consistency and interrater reliability for this study’s sample were comparable to previous studies’ (Santirso et al, 2018, 2020).…”

Motivational Strategies in Interventions for Intimate Partner Violence Offenders: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials

“…Despite these limitations, this review points to the potential benefits of integrating motivational strategies into IPV offender programs to increase intervention adherence and reduce dropout. Also, sustained integration of motivational strategies throughout the delivery of IPV intervention program could lead to more substantial gains than the use of a single session motivational strategy, increasing long-term effects of these programs Santirso et al, 2020). Additionally, matching the appropriate intervention with participants' readiness to change could help to improve the effectiveness of these programs (Begun et al, 2003;Eckhardt et al, 2004;Levesque et al, 2008).…”

Challenges to an Individualized Approach Toward Batterers Intervention Programs in the Context of Coordinated Community Response to the Intimate Partner Violence in Lithuania

“…As a result, engaging offenders in behavioral correction through motivational interviewing has already become an early component of the correctional process (Stinson & Clark, 2017). Recent studies indicate that motivational strategies improve working alliance and protherapeutic behaviors (Santirso et al, 2020), and conclude that the use of various motivational strategies can significantly contribute to BIP effectiveness (Babcock et al, 2016;Crane & Eckhardt, 2013;Kistenmacher & Weiss, 2008;Lila et al, 2018;Silva et al, 2022).…”