Multifunctionality of agricultural water: looking beyond food production and ecosystem services

Abstract

The concept of multifunctional agriculture recognizes important potential benefits of agriculture in addition to the production of food: environmental services (wildlife habitat, pleasing landscape), food security, rural livelihoods and regional economic vitality, stable households and communities, cultural heritage and identity, and religious, spiritual, and aesthetic values. Agricultural water can also be considered through a multifunctional lens using the same logic, but also adding functions that are specific to water. Through this analysis, water becomes much more valuable than if it is considered as merely an input to agricultural production. Because paddy-based agriculture is based on water, an understanding of paddy's multifunctional nature helps to highlight the multifunctional nature of agricultural water. Four categories of functions are discussed: (1) economic and productive, (2) environmental, (3) sociocultural, and (4) rural development. Policy strategies for supporting these multiple functions are considered based on examples from Europe and Asia. The paper concludes with a discussion of water management and how the multiple functions of water can be incorporated into practical policies. Making wise decisions about water allocations to agriculture depends upon a sound understanding of the multiple benefits that agricultural water provides beyond the agriculture sector. While more research is needed, there is already a great deal of valuable research that has been carried out in the name of agriculture, and which can be applied to the challenges of understanding and managing agricultural water. Copyright # 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.key words: multifunctional agriculture; water management; cost-benefit analysis; rural policy RÉ SUMÉ Le concept de l'agriculture multifonctionnelle met en évidence les importants bénéfices potentiels de l'agriculture au-delà de la production de nourriture: services environnementaux (habitat de la faune, paysage agréable), sécurité alimentaire, emplois ruraux et vitalité économique régionale, foyers et collectivités équilibrés, héritage et identité culturels, et valeurs religieuses, spirituelles et esthétiques. L'eau agricole peut aussi être analysée à travers un prisme multifonctionnel avec la même logique mais en ajoutant les fonctions spécifiques à l'eau. Avec cette analyse, la valeur de l'eau devient beaucoup plus élevée que celle d'un simple intrant dans la fonction de production. Parce que l'agriculture basée sur le paddy repose sur l'eau, la compréhension de la nature multifonctionnelle du paddy permet de mettre en lumière celle de l'eau. Quatre catégories de fonctions sont passées en revue: économique et productive, environnementale, socio-culturelle et développement rural. Les stratégies d'appui à ces fonctions multiples sont examinées à partir d'exemples en Europe et en Asie. L'article conclut en abordant la gestion de l'eau et la façon dont les fonctions multiples de l'eau peuvent être incorporées dans les politiques concrètes. La détermination raison...

Modeling Sustainability of Water, Environment, Livelihood, and Culture in Traditional Irrigation Communities and Their Linked Watersheds

“…These are described variably as studies of farmer-managed or community irrigation systems, water users associations, peasant irrigation systems, traditional acequia institutions, and by other terms [4,[34][35][36][37]. More recently, the ecohydrological interactions, environmental values, and multi-functionality of these gravity flow systems have been the subject of new research that requires interdisciplinary approaches by teams composed of hydrologists, ecologists, agronomists, and human culture scientists [15,[38][39]. Field-based analysis is still needed at watershed and regional river basin scales in semi-arid environments worldwide.…”

On-farm irrigation development and management in lower Myanmar: factors for sustainable rice production and collective action

“…In Myanmar, 90% of harnessed water is used for agriculture. 23 A key priority within the agricultural water sector is the more efficient use of water through 24 on-farm improvement and water management training (Groenfeldt 2006 However, large local variations in yields have been recognized. 33…”

Estimating Willingness to Pay to Protect Acequia Irrigation and Culture: Lessons from San Miguel County, NM

“…Agricultural land provides a variety of ecosystem services, such as open space (Kline & Wichelns, 1994, 1996a, 1996bAdelaja et al, 2006;Adelaja & Lake, 2007;Plantinga & Miller., 2001), wildlife habitat (Nickerson & Lynch 2001), and groundwater recharge (Smith 2006;Fernald et al, 2007;Fernald & Guldan, 2006). This constellation of amenities is also addressed in the agriculture multifunctionality literature (Drake, 1992;Randall, 2002: Rønningen et al, 2004Groenfeldt, 2005). Table 1 displays results from valuation work on agriculture and some other cultural ecosystem services.…”