“…Such extra regularity assumption on the exact solution is essential for analysis of C 1 spline collocation methods that do not involve integrals, but require evaluation of functions at certain quadrature points [7,10,19]. The analysis in [1,2] for finite element Galerkin method with quadrature for a linear biharmonic problem, restricted to the C 1 cubic spline (r = 3) case, requires H r+5 ( ) regularity. As demonstrated in [6,Section 5], the extra regularity assumptions on the solution and coefficients may be required only in quadrature finite element analysis, and may not affect convergence rates in practical computations.…”