The insertion of CO into the terminal Co−OMe bond in (Salophen t-Bu )(MeOH)Co(III)(OMe), which led to the formation of (Salophen t-Bu )(MeOH)Co(III)(COOMe), was investigated without and with the addition of free MeO − . The free MeO − concentration in the reaction system showed a nonlinear influence on the carbonylation rate, and the fastest rate was observed upon the addition of 1.8 equiv of MeO − , referred to as the methoxocobalt complex. Two classical migratory insertion-based pathways and a direct CO insertion-based pathway were envisioned to occur in the reaction system and be responsible for the production of (Salophen t-Bu )(MeOH)Co(III)(COOMe). Two of these three reaction pathways could be promoted by the addition of MeO − , thus yielding an overall mechanism that could be tuned based on the concentration of free MeO − in the reaction system. Furthermore, the anionic [(Salophen t-Bu )Co-(III)(OMe) 2 ] − , a key intermediate in the direct CO insertion-based pathway, was independently synthesized and characterized. The reactivity of (Salophen t-Bu )(MeOH)Co(III)(COOMe) as a potential methoxy carbonyl radical-yielding reagent under light irradiation was also examined.