Patient Innovation: An Analysis of Patients' Designs of Digital Technology Support for Everyday Living with Diabetes

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to identify characteristics of patients' contributions to innovation in health information technology (HIT). The paper outlines a theoretical definition of patient innovation and presents an analysis of four digital prototypes and 22 low-fidelity mock-ups designed by people affected by the chronic illness diabetes mellitus. Seventeen families (a total of 60 people) with one or more diabetic family members participated in design activities in a four-year research project focused on the design of digital support for everyday living with diabetes. Our analysis documented the originality of the analysed patient designs and identified three characteristics of patients' designs: socio-technical networks, objects with associated personal meanings and technology supporting the expression of identity. The paper concludes that patient innovation is defined by what is perceived as new by patients and/or others within the social system of adaptation. The analysed patient designs are original (as distinct from replications of or improvements on known products), and their characteristics are innovative contributions to the social system of everyday living with diabetes (i.e. they are perceived as new to the patients in the research study). The results of the analysis contribute to the credentials of patients as key actors in HIT innovation and call for participatory approaches in health informatics.

Digital health now and in the future: Findings from a participatory design stakeholder workshop

“…In another study, Wherton and colleagues 37 conducted participatory design workshops with users of telehealth and telecare, their carers, service providers and technology suppliers. Another study 38 involved people with diabetes and their families in co-creating ideas and prototypes for digital technologies to support everyday living with the disease.…”

User involvement in the development of a telehealth solution to improve the kidney transplantation process: A participatory design study

“…Valuable mutual learning emerged between the participants throughout the development process. The significance of user involvement is emphasised by Kanstrup et al, 32 who found that, as key actors, patients can provide original designs that combine everyday living with medical technology in a way designers could not have done by themselves. This was similar in our study; the features and the content of the app and the workflow were developed in cooperation with patients and HCPs, which has been important for the usability in clinical practice.…”

Development of an individualized asynchronous sensor-based telerehabilitation program for patients undergoing total knee replacement: Participatory design

“…The first working group (consisting of the patients, two researchers, and a facilitator) sought to collect insight into the user’s needs and system requirements. Brainstorming, paper prototypes, drawing an idea, graphical user interface (GUI) design, 41,42 and guided discussion methods regarding the technical restrictions were all used in order to illuminate the patients’ needs (see Table 1).…”