“…Of the three implementations of learning science in the lower grades (grades 1,2 and 3) Islamic Elementary School using the STAD and jigsaw cooperative learning models can make students more independent, foster social attitudes (Marheni, Jampel, and Suwatra, 2020) and good cooperation, respect each other and make students more active (Rahmah, Kafrawi, and Mahsul, 2019) and students look more friendly with other students, can also improve student learning outcomes (Marheni, Jampel, and Suwatra 2020) Increased student confidence even though when presenting the results of the discussion it is still not smooth and is still guided by the teacher.…”