Perfectionism and L2 Achievement: The Mediating Roles of Motivation and Self-Regulated Learning Among Iranian High School Students

Abstract

The current study investigated how perfectionism can be related to L2 learners’ achievement with motivation and two aspects of self-regulated learning as possible mediators. This study also evaluated the factor structure of the Big Three Perfectionism Scale (BTPS) in an Iranian sample. The participants were 495 Iranian high school students who completed six BTPS sub-scales and measures of self-determined motivation and self-regulated learning. Psychometric analyses indicated that rigid perfectionism and self-critical perfectionism as two higher order factors have construct validity. Structural equation modeling indicated that rigid perfectionism positively predicted L2 achievement, while self-critical perfectionism negatively predicted L2 achievement. Mediational models indicated that neither autonomous-mastery/performance motivation nor controlled motivation mediated the path from perfectionism to L2 achievement. However, both aspects of self-regulated learning, namely, deep learning and persistence could mediate the relationship between perfectionism and L2 achievement. Specifically, higher levels of self-critical perfectionism were positively related to deep learning and persistence that, in turn, were related to higher L2 achievement. In contrast, self-critical perfectionism was negatively related to deep learning and persistence, that, in turn, were related to lower L2 achievement. The results are discussed in terms of the practical implications for L2 teachers and parents.

Perfectionism and writing anxiety as predictors of Iranian EFL learners’ performance in IELTS writing module: a multi-dimensional perspective

“…Also, higher scores in perfectionism were associated with higher scores in trait anxiety, suggesting that more perfectionist students would experience higher levels of trait anxiety. Chasetareh et al (2023) investigated the relationship between perfectionism and EFL learners' achievement, considering motivation and self-regulated learning as possible mediators. Their findings revealed that "higher levels of rigid perfectionism were positively related to deep learning and persistence that, in turn, were related to higher L2 achievement. "…”

You just want a break from the hatred of failure: the lived experience of being a student physiotherapist perfectionist and considerations for educators

“…Persistence and the use of deep learning strategies is clearly advantageous to learning, and has been articulated as such in various perfectionism studies (e.g. Chasetareh et al, 2023 ; Mills & Blankstein, 2000 ; Vogel et al, 2019 ). However, this study indicates that the learning process is painfully slow, necessitates huge personal costs, and robs perfectionists of any gratification to be gained.…”

Group dynamic assessment vs. computerized dynamic assessment: impacts on L2 listening development, L2 students’ perfectionism, foreign language anxiety, and intrinsic motivation

“…These researchers concluded that we are better able to comprehend the L2 listening process thanks to the patterns of interaction between perfectionism and the two listening subprocesses. Chasetareh et al (2022) examined the relationship between perfectionism and L2 learners' accomplishment, looking at motivation and two components of self-regulated learning as potential mediators. The Big Three Perfectionism Scale (BTPS) factor structure was also assessed in this study using an Iranian population.…”