“…Furthermore, and more relevant to the theme of this special issue, this paper outlines a specific way of approaching the process of digitalisation, and the enactment of smart consumers. While there is now an emerging body of work within marketing and consumption studies, which is interested in smart consumers (Balaji & Roy, 2017) and the digitalisation of consumption more generally, much of this research has been geared towards either analysing cases in which smart technologies work (Balaji & Roy, 2017;Canhoto & Arp, 2017) or trying to determine barriers to the introduction and acceptance of smart technologies (Mani & Chouk, 2017;Roya, Balajib, Quazic, & Quaddus, 2018). In relation to this body of work, this study shows that our understanding of the opportunities and problems associated with smart consumers, and their making and makings, can be improved by understanding failures to enact smart consumers.…”