Primitive Socialist Accumulation in China: An Alternative View on the Anomalies of Chinese “Capitalism”

Abstract

China’s economic system has yet to be adequately explained by any models. China’s export-led industries were initially viewed as a source of cheap labor but its economy has now emerged as a serious competitor to advanced capitalism. However, after decades of market reform, China’s state sector, rather than disappearing or being marginalized, has become a leader in strategic sectors and the driver of its investment-led growth. Heterodox political scientists and economists have long argued that China is at best a variant within global capitalism. This paper discusses heterodox theories that position China as part of global capitalism or regard it as a variety of capitalism. It then examines the anomalies of Chinese “capitalism” and suggests that primitive socialist accumulation—operating in conflict with capitalist accumulation—offers a more appropriate theoretical framework for studying China’s development. JEL Classification: B51, O10, O53, P21, P26

A Polycentric World Will Only Be Possible by the Intervention of the “Sixth Great Power”

“…Paris Yeros https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4200-1808 Notes 1. For various dimensions of the development successes and challenges today, see Amin (2013), Mohanty (2018), Cheng (2020), Wen (2021), Kadri (2021), Gabriele and Jabbour (2022) employers, employed labor (wage and salaried), own account labor, contributing family labor, the unemployed, and those not in the workforce (a heterogenous category encompassing those who are no longer looking for a job, students, the sick, incapacitated, and early retirees, and the caretakers of the household, including of the young, the old, and the sick). These categories, although imperfect for our needs, remain useful in capturing basic trends in the formation of labor reserves.…”

“…1.For various dimensions of the development successes and challenges today, see Amin (2013), Mohanty (2018), Cheng (2020), Wen (2021), Kadri (2021), Gabriele and Jabbour (2022), and Sit et al (2023). …”

Os Limites Estruturais do Capital de Mészáros e os Limites da Guerra à China

“…A China também tem demonstrado que pode reestruturar o seu próprio mercado doméstico para o alcance de objetivos estatais de médio e longo prazo, o que fortalece a tese que centraliza a importância do aparato estatal multiforme e do crescimento da demanda interna como propulsores da acumulação socialista chinesa (CHENG, 2020;JABBOUR e GABRIELE, 2021). O impacto desse desenvolvimento é cada vez mais sentido diretamente pela economia mundial capitalista.…”

The “Lucky Money” That Started It All—The Reinvention of the Ancient Tradition “Red Packet” in Digital Times

“…While the Chinese gift economy serves as an informal version of resource exchange, China’s socialist market economy is ascribed to the adoption of capitalism under the supervision of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP; Cheng, 2020). State-owned banks dominate financing governance, and all capital exchanges are under strict scrutiny of the CCP (Peck & Zhang, 2013).…”