Qualitative research: its value and applicability

Abstract

Qualitative research has a rich tradition in the social sciences. Since the late 19th century, researchers interested in studying the social behaviour and cultures of humankind have perceived limitations in trying to explain the phenomena they encounter in purely quantifiable, measurable terms. Anthropology, in its social and cultural forms, was one of the foremost disciplines in developing what would later be termed a qualitative approach, founded as it was on ethnographic studies which sought an understanding of the culture of people from other societies, often hitherto unknown and far removed in geography. 1Early researchers would spend extended periods of time living in societies, observing, noting and photographing the minutia of daily life, with the most committed often learning the language of peoples they observed, in the hope of gaining greater acceptance by them and a more detailed understanding of the cultural norms at play. All academic disciplines concerned with human and social behaviour, including anthropology, sociology and psychology, now make extensive use of qualitative research methods whose systematic application was first developed by these colonial-era social scientists.Their methods, involving observation, participation and discussion of the individuals and groups being studied, as well as reading related textual and visual media and artefacts, form the bedrock of all qualitative social scientific inquiry. The general aim of qualitative research is thus to develop concepts which help us to understand social phenomena in, wherever possible, natural rather than experimental settings, to gain an understanding of the experiences, perceptions and/or behaviours of those studied, and the meanings attached to them.2 Researchers interested in finding out why people behave the way they do; how people are affected by events, how attitudes and opinions are formed; how and why cultures and practices have developed in the way they have, might well consider qualitative methods to answer their questions.What questions are best answered using qualitative research?It is fair to say that clinical and health-related research is still dominated by quantitative methods, of which the randomised controlled trial, focused on hypothesis-testing through experiment controlled by randomisation, is perhaps the quintessential method. Qualitative approaches may seem obscure to the uninitiated when directly compared with the experimental, quantitative methods used in clinical research. There is increasing recognition among researchers in these fields, however, that qualitative methods such as observation, in-depth interviews, focus groups, consensus methods, case studies and the interpretation of texts can be more effective than quantitative approaches in exploring complex phenomena and as such are valuable additions to the methodological armoury available to them. 3In considering what kind of research questions are best answered using a qualitative approach, it is important to remember that, first and foremost, unlike q...

Investigating the impact of headaches on the quality of life of patients with glioblastoma multiforme: a qualitative study

“…When investigating the complexity of human behaviour, a qualitative approach may more likely highlight these due to the themes that emerge when participants are allowed to discuss what is important to them. 20 Such an approach has been successful in similar research in patients with other cancers and congenital heart disease. 21 22 Additionally, due to the limited time frame and resources, the feasibility of recruiting a sample size capable of statistical significance from questionnaire data would have been low.…”

Psychiatry, subjectivity and emotion – deepening the medical model

“… 27 Qualitative research, long established in the social sciences as a legitimate method for data collection, analysis and interpretation, but criticised for not fulfilling the objective criteria of reliability or validity satisfied by quantitative research, is enjoying a resurgence of interest in clinical and health-related research and may be more effective than quantitative approaches in exploring the complex phenomena of human behaviour. 28 …”

Can Adults with Mild Cognitive Impairment Build Cognitive Reserve and Learn Mindfulness Meditation? Qualitative Theme Analyses from a Small Pilot Study

“…Qualitative research is a powerful complement to quantitative methodology that allows researchers to explore complex phenomena to gain a better understanding of the meaning of findings. [23,24] The recent burgeoning of the scientific exploration of mind-body interventions has led many researchers to use qualitative research to elucidate mechanisms and perceived benefits. [25][26][27][28] As these interventions are complex, qualitative methods can help researchers appreciate nuances that may be challenging to assess with current quantitative instruments.…”