Rainforest Pharmacopeia in Madagascar Provides High Value for Current Local and Prospective Global Uses

Abstract

Botanical diversity provides value to humans through carbon sequestration, air and water purification, and the provisioning of wild foods and ethnomedicines. Here we calculate the value of botanical ethnomedicines in a rainforest region of Madagascar, the Makira Protected Area, using a substitution method that combines replacement costs and choice modeling. The Makira watershed may comprise approximately 0.8% of global botanical diversity and possesses enormous value both in its ability to provision botanical ethnomedicines to local people and as a source of potentially novel pharmaceutical drugs for society as a whole. Approximately 241 locally-recognized species are used as ethnomedicines, including 113 agricultural or weed species. We equated each ethnomedicinal treatment to the monetary value of a comparable pharmaceutical treatment adjusted by personal preferences in perceived efficacy (rather than from known or assumed medicinal equivalency). The benefit value of these botanical ethnomedicines per individual is $5.40–7.90 per year when using the value of highly subsidized Malagasy pharmaceuticals and $100.60–287.40 when using the value of American pharmaceuticals. Using local pharmaceuticals as substitutes, the value per household is $30.24–44.30 per year, equivalent to 43–63% of median annual household income, demonstrating their local importance. Using the value of American pharmaceuticals, the amount is equivalent to 22–63% of the median annual health care expenditures for American adults under 45 in 2006. The potential for developing novel biomedicines from the Makira watershed’s unique flora ranges in untapped benefit value from $0.3–5.7 billion for American pharmaceutical companies, non-inclusive of the importance of providing novel medicines and improved healthcare to society. This study provides evidence of the tremendous current local and prospective global value of botanical ethnomedicines and furthers arguments for the conservation of tropical forests for sustainable use.Botanique de la diversité apporte de la valeur à l’homme par la séquestration du carbone, de l’air et de purification de l’eau, et le provisionnement des aliments sauvages et ethnomedicines. Ici, nous calculons la valeur de ethnomedicines botaniques dans une région de forêt de Madagascar, la zone protégée de Makira, en utilisant une méthode de substitution qui combine les coûts de remplacement et la modélisation des choix. Le bassin versant de Makira peut comprendre environ 0,8% de la diversité botanique mondiale et possède une valeur énorme à la fois dans sa capacité à fournir ethnomedicines botaniques à la population locale et en tant que source de nouveaux médicaments potentiellement pharmaceutiques pour la société dans son ensemble. Environ 241 espèces localement reconnus sont utilisés comme ethnomedicines, y compris 113 espèces d’agricoles ou de mauvaises herbes. Nous assimilé chaque traitement ethnomédicales à la valeur monétaire d’un traitement comparable pharmaceutique ajusté en fonction des préférences personnelles en ma...

The human health and conservation relevance of food taboos in northeastern Madagascar

“…Only men were interviewed because the original study design was targeted to understand patterns of hunting (a discussion of the effects of this sampling frame can be found in Golden and Comaroff 2015). In addition to a variety of other questions concerning wildlife harvest (Golden 2009, ethnomedicinal use (Golden et al 2012a), and the eating of nonfood items, i.e., geophagy, or the consumption of earth or soil (Golden et al 2012b), the survey covered numerous topics, including household composition and economy, resource extraction behaviors, educational achievement, and religious and ethnic group affiliations. Quantitative information on the annual consumption rates of individual wildlife species was collected each year and has been validated as an accurate survey instrument (Golden et al 2013).…”

Global benefits and local costs – The dilemma of tropical forest conservation: A review of the situation in Madagascar

“…For most medicinal plants, the exchange value associated with single plants is uncertain (Méral et al 2006), but they represent a low-cost alternative to western medicine. For the Makira protected area, Golden et al (2012) estimated an average of 82 treatments per year with botanical ethnomedicine from the forest having an equivalent value of US$30.24−44.30 per household and year. An important exported medicinal plant growing in forests is the bark of Prunus africana, which can generate more than 30% of a village's revenue (Péchard et al 2005).…”

Socio - ecological analysis of natural resource use in Betampona Strict Natural Reserve

“…Natural resources often play a critical role in human health and livelihoods and many suggest that conservation should attempt to meet all basic human needs (i.e., Kaimowitz and Sheil 2007). In Madagascar, more than 92 % of people live on less than $US 2/day (World Bank 2013) and thus natural resources Madagascar, several types of natural resources have been shown to play a major role in human livelihoods, through local use of honey (Kremen et al 1999), construction materials (Kremen et al 1999), traditional medicines (Golden et al 2012a), soils/earth (Golden et al 2012b), and the environment's role in spiritual and cultural practice (i.e., Keller 2009, Golden 2014). Because of the environment's tremendous value to local people in poverty alleviation (e.g., Gardner et al 2013), conservation can serve to exacerbate conflict over resources, especially when resources are critical for human livelihoods or survival (West and Brockington 2006).…”