Receiver operating characteristic analysis for intelligent medical systems-a new approach for finding confidence intervals

Abstract

Intelligent systems are increasingly being deployed in medicine and healthcare, but there is a need for a robust and objective methodology for evaluating such systems. Potentially, receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis could form a basis for the objective evaluation of intelligent medical systems. However, it has several weaknesses when applied to the types of data used to evaluate intelligent medical systems. First, small data sets are often used, which are unsatisfactory with existing methods. Second, many existing ROC methods use parametric assumptions which may not always be valid for the test cases selected. Third, system evaluations are often more concerned with particular, clinically meaningful, points on the curve, rather than on global indexes such as the more commonly used area under the curve. A novel, robust and accurate method is proposed, derived from first principles, which calculates the probability density function (pdf) for each point on a ROC curve for any given sample size. Confidence intervals are produced as contours on the pdf. The theoretical work has been validated by Monte Carlo simulations. It has also been applied to two real-world examples of ROC analysis, taken from the literature (classification of mammograms and differential diagnosis of pancreatic diseases), to investigate the confidence surfaces produced for real cases, and to illustrate how analysis of system performance can be enhanced. We illustrate the impact of sample size on system performance from analysis of ROC pdf's and 95% confidence boundaries. This work establishes an important new method for generating pdf's, and provides an accurate and robust method of producing confidence intervals for ROC curves for the small sample sizes typical of intelligent medical systems. It is conjectured that, potentially, the method could be extended to determine risks associated with the deployment of intelligent medical systems in clinical practice.

Heartbeat biometrics: a sensing system perspective

“…Verification is evaluated using ROC curves to characterise detection performance versus false alarm rate (FAR). Tilbury et al (2000) and Theofanos et al (2007) explored the role of confidence intervals in biometric verification.…”

Automated Detection of Hematological Abnormalities through Classification of Flow Cytometric Data Patterns

“…Receiver Operating Characteristics (ROC) Analysis [Tilbury et al 2000]. Such analysis begins by establishing a confusion matrix which contains information about the actual classification of the data being tested and the outcome of the classification system.…”

Early Breast Cancer Prognosis Prediction and Rule Extraction Using a New Constructive Neural Network Algorithm

“…To quantify the performances of the methods, the generalization ability was measured together with the balanced generalization ability defined as the average between the generalization observed for positive and negative cases. Another estimator of the performance of the methods that is often used and preferred in medical prognosis is the area under the ROC plot [6,7,8], that we also compute for the different methods.…”