Mandibular incisors scheduled for extraction were subjected or not to three 15-minute applications of a 35% hydrogen peroxide gel. Two days thereafter, bleaching effectiveness (according to a value-oriented shade guide) was evaluated, and histological analysis of pulp tissue was performed. Immediately and two days after bleaching, tooth sensitivity (TS) experience was recorded. Bleached teeth of both groups showed significant color improvement (Mann-Whitney; p < 0.05). However, these teeth presented significant pulp alterations when compared with non-bleached teeth (Mann-Whitney; p < 0.05), including areas of superficial necrosis associated with mild inflammatory reactions. These data were achieved by recordings of TS immediately after bleaching (Fisher's exact test; p<0.05), which was reduced with time. Instead of 'no significant difference' being observed between young and old teeth (Mann-Whitney; p<0.05), necrosis occurred in 60% of old bleached teeth in comparison with 100% of young teeth, associated with underlying tertiary dentin deposition. It was concluded that, regardless of the age of patients, the application of a 35%-HP bleaching gel to mandibular incisors causes pulp damage, which was related to initial TS; however, superficial necrosis was more prevalent in young teeth.