Response to environmental factors and competition: skull, mandible and tooth shapes in Polish water shrews (Neomys, Soricidae, Mammalia)

Abstract

Environmental factors and competition in closely related sympatric species may result in character displacement or phenotypic convergence. We studied the effects of sympatry on size and shape of the skulls, mandibles and molars in two species of water shrew, Neomys anomalus and Neomys fodiens. We studied populations from six localities in Poland, three where the species are sympatric (Pomorze, Białowie_ za, and Bieszczady Mts) and three where only N. fodiens is found. We studied shape and size using geometrical landmarks. The three morphological structures that we studied are expected to respond differently to environment and competition, because they are controlled by different numbers of gene loci, have different developmental patterns and different functional roles. We found strong evidence that shape in all three structures was influenced by local environment and that both species responded to geoclimatic factors in the same way. Indirect evidence suggests that the parallel response of the two species is likely to be ecophenotypic in the case of skulls and mandibles but selective in molars. We found no evidence for character displacement in either size or shape, although significant differences were found between the two species as a whole, and within species between localities. Not only was there any evidence for displacement but also the species were actually more similar when they occurred in sympatry, probably because of the similar ecophenotypic responses to their shared environment.

Biogeographic Analysis Using Geometric Morphometrics: Clines in Skull Size and Shape in a Widespread African Arboreal Monkey

“…Two-block partial least squares (2B-PLS) has also been used to analyze the effects of geography and climate on geometric morphometric measurements of morphology (e.g. Fadda and Corti 2001;Rychlik et al 2006) but with similar differences to our approach.…”

A comparative assessment of mandible shape in a consomic strain panel of the house mouse (Mus musculus) - implications for epistasis and evolvability of quantitative traits

“…While the relationship between mandible shape and ecological niche has been investigated for several taxa at the level of between-species diversity or higher [28-33], so far only one study conducted on shrews found intraspecific covariation between mandible shape and environmental variables [34]. In the mouse mandible, environmental influences have traditionally been investigated using hard diet vs. soft diet experiments, and diet consistency has indeed been found to influence mandible growth and shape [15,16,35-37].…”

Morphometrics for Nonmorphometricians

“…Fadda and Corti 2001;Rychlik et al 2006) but with similar differences to our approach. Ours is not the only approach to this problem, but it is closely related and, we argue, more sophisticated than most.…”