Preload and afterload dictate the dynamics of the cyclical work-loop contraction that the heart undergoes in vivo. Cellular Ca2+ dynamics drive contraction, but the effects of afterload alone on the Ca2+ transient are inconclusive. No study has investigated whether the putative afterload dependence of the Ca2+ transient is preload dependent. This study is designed to provide the first insight into the Ca2+ handling of cardiac trabeculae undergoing work-loop contractions, with the aim to examine whether the conflicting afterload dependency of the Ca2+ transient can be accounted for by considering preload under isometric and physiological work‑loop contractions. Thus, we subjected ex vivo rat right-ventricular trabeculae, loaded with the fluorescent dye Fura‑2, to work‑loop contractions over a wide range of afterloads at two preloads while measuring stress, length changes, and Ca2+ transients. Work‑loop control was implemented with a real-time Windkessel model to mimic the contraction patterns of the heart in vivo. We extracted a range of metrics from the measured steady‑state twitch stress and Ca2+ transients, including the amplitudes, time courses, rates of rise, and integrals. Results show that parameters of stress were afterload and preload dependent. In contrast, the parameters associated with Ca2+ transients displayed a mixed dependence on afterload and preload. Most notably, its time course was afterload-dependent - an effect augmented at the greater preload. This study reveals that the afterload dependence of cardiac Ca2+ transients is modulated by preload, which brings the study of Ca2+ transients during isometric contractions into question when aiming to understand physiological Ca2+ handling.