Small class sizes for improving student achievement in primary and secondary schools: a systematic review

Abstract

This Campbell systematic review examines the impact of class size on academic achievement. The review summarises findings from 148 reports from 41 countries. Ten studies were included in the meta‐analysis. Included studies concerned children in grades kindergarten to 12 (or the equivalent in European countries) in general education. The primary focus was on measures of academic achievement. All study designs that used a well‐defined control group were eligible for inclusion. A total of 127 studies, consisting of 148 papers, met the inclusion criteria. These 127 studies analysed 55 different populations from 41 different countries. A large number of studies (45) analysed data from the Student Teacher Achievement Ratio (STAR) experiment which was for class size reduction in grade K‐3 in the US in the eighties. However only ten studies, including four of the STAR programme, could be included in the meta‐analysis. Overall, the evidence suggests at best a small effect on reading achievement. There is a negative, but statistically insignificant, effect on mathematics. For the non‐STAR studies the primary study effect sizes for reading were close to zero but the weighted average was positive and statistically significant. There was some inconsistency in the direction of the primary study effect sizes for mathematics and the weighted average effect was negative and statistically non‐significant. The STAR results are more positive, but do not change the overall finding. All reported results from the studies analysing STAR data indicated a positive effect of smaller class sizes for both reading and maths, but the average effects are small Plain language summary Small class size has at best a small effect on academic achievementReducing class size is seen as a way of improving student performance. But larger class sizes help control education budgets. The evidence suggests at best a small effect on reading achievement. There is a negative, but statistically insignificant, effect on mathematics, so it cannot be ruled out that some children may be adversely affected. What is this review about?Increasing class size is one of the key variables that policy makers can use to control spending on education.But the consensus among many in education research is that smaller classes are effective in improving student achievement which has led to a policy of class size reductions in a number of US states, the UK, and the Netherlands. This policy is disputed by those who argue that the effects of class size reduction are only modest and that there are other more cost‐effective strategies for improving educational standards.Despite the important policy and practice implications of the topic, the research literature on the educational effects of class‐size differences has not been clear.This review systematically reports findings from relevant studies that measure the effects of class size on academic achievement. What are the main findings of this review?What studies are included?Included studies concerned children in grades kindergarten...

The motivation of learning art & culture among students in Indonesia

“…The result of this study is supported by DeMonbrun et al (2017) that states learning achievement is obtained due to the selection of appropriate and quality learning methods. If the teacher can apply the learning method correctly and precisely depends on the needs in class, it brings a positive impact on improving student learning achievement at school (Filges et al, 2018;Yang et al, 2020). One favorite method for students is the discussion method.…”

The Potential of Telepresence for Increasing Advanced Course Access in High Schools

“…The program features implemented in MPS—including relatively small class sizes, robust professional development, best practices sharing among instructors, and networking and relationship building between teachers and students across classrooms and outside the school day to cultivate presence—appeared to contribute to positive overall experiences for students and teachers in telepresence courses (Filges, Sonne-Schmidt, & Nielsen, 2018; Van Driel & Berry, 2012). Without these features, such positive results would likely not have been possible.…”

The Relationship between Social Environmental Factors and Motor Performance in 3- to 12-Year-Old Typically Developing Children: A Systematic Review

“…Two studies, investigating the same study sample, found no relationship [ 34 , 35 ], while another study found a relationship but did not define the direction of the relationship [ 48 ]. Previous research suggests that a higher number of students in a class might be related to poorer motor skills, because the available resources such as space to move around and teachers’ time and attention are more diluted [ 58 , 80 ]. However, a review has shown that the effect of class size on other domains such as academic achievement is small at best [ 80 ].…”