This work aimed to synthesize a novel dimethacrylated-derivative of eugenol (Eg) (termed EgGAA) as potential biomaterial for certain applications such as dental fillings and adhesives. EgGAA was synthesized through a two-step reaction: (i) a mono methacrylated-eugenol (EgGMA) was produced via a ring-opening etherification of glycidyl methacrylate (GMA) with Eg; (ii) EgGMA was condensed with methacryloyl chloride into EgGAA. EgGAA was further incorporated in matrices containing BisGMA and TEGDMA (50:50 wt%) (TBEa), in which EgGAA replaced BisGMA as 0–100 wt% to get a series of unfilled resin composites (TBEa0–TBEa100), and by addition of reinforcing silica (66 wt%), a series of filled resins were also obtained (F-TBEa0–F-TBEa100). Synthesized monomers were analyzed for their structural, spectral, and thermal properties using FTIR, 1H- and 13C-NMR, mass spectrometry, TGA, and DSC. Composites rheological and DC were analyzed. The viscosity (η, Pa·s) of EgGAA (0.379) was 1533 times lower than BisGMA (581.0) and 125 times higher than TEGDMA (0.003). Rheology of unfilled resins (TBEa) indicated Newtonian fluids, with viscosity decreased from 0.164 Pa·s (TBEa0) to 0.010 Pa·s (TBEa100) when EgGAA totally replaced BisGMA. However, composites showed non-Newtonian and shear-thinning behavior, with complex viscosity (η*) being shear-independent at high angular frequencies (10–100 rad/s). The loss factor crossover points were at 45.6, 20.3, 20.4, and 25.6 rad/s, indicating a higher elastic portion for EgGAA-free composite. The DC was insignificantly decreased from 61.22% for the control to 59.85% and 59.50% for F-TBEa25 and F-TBEa50, respectively, while the difference became significant when EgGAA totally replaced BisGMA (F-TBEa100, DC = 52.54%). Accordingly, these properties could encourage further investigation of Eg-containing resin-based composite as filling materials in terms of their physicochemical, mechanical, and biological potentiality as dental material.