TASER Electronic Control Devices and Cardiac Arrests: Coincidental or Causal?

Abstract

Being arrested is a highly emotional event and can result in a fatal, adrenergically supercharged physiological state. 1 The exertion of arrest-related struggle is several-fold greater than that seen with normal exercise and leads to numerous extreme metabolic and electrolytic derangements, including elevated levels of lactate, CO 2 , potassium, creatine kinase, and myoglobin.2 Only 1.6% of US law-enforcement interactions involve the use or threats of force, and annually there are ≈700 000 cases in which force is used or threatened.3 There are ≈700 arrest-related deaths per year in the United States, yielding a mortality rate of ≈1 in 1000 for a law-enforcement interaction associated with force. 4 Response by Zipes on p 100The electronic control device (ECD) has gained widespread acceptance as the force option for law enforcement because of its dramatic reduction in both suspect and officer injury. At the same time, advocacy groups post statements on the Internet listing the hundreds of arrest-related deaths after ECD use with the implication that the ECD involvement was causal. Studies covering a total of >48 000 forceful arrests have consistently found suspect injury rate reductions of ≈65%.5,6 Of the 250 000 annual ECD field uses in the United States, only 1 in 4000 is involved in an arrest-related death. This reduction in fatality rate is consistent with published data showing that 5.4% of ECD uses "clearly prevented the use of lethal force by police." 7Of the >3 million total ECD applications, there have been 12 published case reports suggesting a potential cardiac arrest link, giving an incidence of 4×10 −6 per application. [8][9][10][11][12][13] In most cases, those authors did not consider important factors that are now better understood. These include separating postural from cardiovascular collapse, the latency of electrically induced ventricular fibrillation (VF), the presence of significant cardiac pathology, failure of prompt defibrillation, the duration of documented breathing, the distance of the ECD electrode from the heart, and the stability of electrically induced VF. We have thoroughly investigated these cases as either TASER scientific advisors or expert witnesses. The goal of this article is to resolve the confusion about these cases by introducing more complete data and by using a consistent case-report scoring methodology. Methods Understanding the Confounders Postural Versus Cardiovascular CollapseIn the normal course of life, an exertional postural collapse is, correctly, often associated with a cardiac arrest. However, it is sometimes forgotten that the ECD design goal is to cause a postural collapse to stop aggression. A sternal rub response is often blunted by the presence of alcohol, illegal drugs, psychotic break, and endorphins from the struggle. Hence, nonresponsiveness is also more difficult to evaluate in the law-enforcement scenario.(Circulation. 2014;129:93-100)

The Right to Explanation, Explained

“…In particular, individual transparency rights largely occur after the fact of algorithmic development, when it is far more difficult (if not impossible) to impose accountability or corrections on a system. 152 By contrast, the GDPR's systemic accountability measures are envisioned as ongoing and continuous, 153 and should be implemented early on in an algorithm's development. This creates, in theory at least, internal, expert/third-party, and regulatory oversight over the development of an algorithm from its inception, better serving the instrumental purposes of correcting error, inaccuracy, and bias in a changing system, over time.…”

Tough Mudder Injuries, Triathlon Drownings, and Team Rhabdomyolysis in the Navy

“…One young man experienced a stroke during the event, and four patients were hurt by electrical shocks to the head, chest, or back, including one with electrical burn marks and one who fell when shocked in the head and landed face first in hard dirt (6). The diagnoses of myocarditis and possible pericarditis from electrical shock (in two of these patients) seem implausible, but they bring to mind the hot debate on how often TASER causes fatal ventricular fibrillation and how to prevent this tragedy (8,16). At least the robust TASER debate has vital social merit, because the TASER also saves lives.…”

Scissors Mode of162Dy Studied from Resonance Neutron Capture

“…Unfortunately, the SM strength of even-even rareearth nuclei from 3 He-induced experiments [8][9][10][11] reaches ΣB(SM) ↑= 6 − 7μ 2 N , which is in disagreement with mutually consistent results from NRF and neutron capture experiments on Gd isotopes [12][13][14][15].…”