Background We aimed to validate Decipher to predict adverse pathology (AP) at radical prostatectomy (RP) in men with National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN) favorable-intermediate risk (F-IR) prostate cancer (PCa), and to better select FIR candidates for active surveillance (AS). Methods In all, 647 patients diagnosed with NCCN very low/low risk (VL/LR) or FIR prostate cancer were identified from a multi-institutional PCa biopsy database; all underwent RP with complete postoperative clinicopathological information and Decipher genomic risk scores. The performance of all risk assessment tools was evaluated using logistic regression model for the endpoint of AP, defined as grade group 3−5, pT3b or higher, or lymph node invasion. Results The median age was 61 years (interquartile range 56-66) for 220 patients with NCCN FIR disease, 53% classified as low-risk by Cancer of the Prostate Risk Assessment (CAPRA 0−2) and 47% as intermediate-risk (CAPRA 3−5). Decipher classified 79%, 13% and 8% of men as low-, intermediate-and high-risk with 13%, 10%, and 41% rate of AP, respectively. Decipher was an independent predictor of AP with an odds ratio of 1.34 per 0.1 unit increased (p value = 0.002) and remained significant when adjusting by CAPRA. Notably, FIR with Decipher low or intermediate score did not associate with significantly higher odds of AP compared to VL/LR. Conclusions NCCN risk groups, including FIR , are highly heterogeneous and should be replaced with multivariable riskstratification. In particular, incorporating Decipher may be useful for safely expanding the use of AS in this patient population.