Industrial acceptanceof metal additive manufacturing (AM) is continuously rising along with its rapid development. As such, continuous research is needed to better understand the process and print characteristics to control and improve process parameters and as-built part quality. Dimensional tolerance, surface characteristics, and mechanical properties are all key qualities to assess for printer performance enhancement and repeatability. This paper presents results for physical and mechanical property inspections and testing on a designed test artifact for the benchmarking of 3D metal printers. The properties investigated include tensile strength, hardness, dimensional accuracy, roughness, and dross formation on overhanging features. Printed artifact results show similar anisotropic mechanical properties, with tensile strengths within the manufacturer-rated ranges. Dimensional XY-plane tolerances were within -0.18 to 0.18 mm and Z-axis tolerance within -0.10 to 0.10 mm for both printers. As-built roughness values were below manufacturer maximums for both Ra and Rz. The overhang performance was similar for both machines, with increasing dross for decreasing overhang angles.