“…The requirements on the PRE/evening vertical drift and the height of the F layer for the spread F "on" and "off" conditions and its varying growth rates and intensities have been widely discussed in the literature (e.g., Farley et al, 1970;Abdu et al, 1983Abdu et al, , 2006Fejer et al, 1999;Sultan, 1996;Sastri et al, 1997). Models have been developed to investigate the effects of the evening zonal electric fields, F layer bottom-side density gradients, and zonal, meridional and vertical winds on the ESF instability development conditions (e.g., Zalesak et al, 1982;Sekar et al, 1994;Maruyama, 1988;Keskinen et al, 2003;Kudeki et al, 2007;Kherani et al, 2009a). An important prerequisite concerns the nature and the intensity of the density perturbation needed to initiate the instability growth, which appears to be the least understood aspect of the ESF processes.…”