The Lack of Collaboration Between Companies and Schools in the German Dual Apprenticeship System: Historical Background and Recent Data

Abstract

On the macro level (federal level) and exo level (state or regional level), the German Dual Apprenticeship System shows a high degree of institutionalised collaboration. However, the companies and vocational schools on the meso level (institutional level and level of the actors), in contrast, are just loosely coupled with a dominant partner (i.e., companies) and a subordinate partner (i.e., vocational schools). How and why these structures have emerged, established and stabilised is part of a complex historical, societal and economical process. The historical developmental will be elaborated in the article. The term ‘dual system’ was invented in Germany in the 1960s, and the intention was to emphasise equal responsibilities, partnership of equals, lively encounters and close collaboration between companies and schools. This vision is not yet a reality, as the presented empirical survey demonstrates. A majority of companies do not or rather seldom collaborate with ‘their’ vocational schools. 74.2% of the companies do not or seldom coordinate their work, and 93% of the companies do not or seldom cooperate with the vocational schools. The German Dual Apprentice­ship System operates on the actual meso level just on the basis of less than 30% of its potentiality. The term ‘parallel systems’ seems to be more appropriate to characterise the actual situation on the meso level than the term ‘dual system’.

Analysis of foreign experience of implementation of the dual form of education and accessibility of its implementation in Ukraine

“…The long history of the formation and development of dual education in such European countries as Germany Austria, Switzerland determines the application of an integrated approach to the study and application of the system in new countries of implementation. The history of formation and the problem of the cooperation of stakeholders of dual education in Germany are covered in [3]. The history of the development of the German model of dual education reveals the dominance of companies in the model and the lack of cooperation between companies and schools.…”

From school to work: Coherence between learning in school and learning in workplaces for apprentices in the Media graphics programme in Norway

“…In previous research, different scholars have revealed different aspects of coherence-related challenges. Recently, Gessler (2017) and Louw (2017) pointed to the lack of cooperation between schools and workplaces in the German and Danish dual apprentice system. Louw's study showed that closer cooperation between the teachers in schools and the instructors in the workplaces enhanced the students' experience of the relationship between the learning arenas.…”

Training marketing by German companies – which training place characteristics are communicated?

“…At the same time, securing one's own demand for skilled workers is the most important reason why German companies participate in dual vocational education and training (Merrilees, W. J. 1983;Niederalt 2005;Jansen, Pfeifer, Schönfeld & Wenzelmann, 2015, Gessler 2017).…”