Satellite-derived sea surface temperatures (SSTs) are increasingly being used as a proxy for water temperature in nearshore marine ecology, but there have been very few evaluations of how accurately SSTs reflect actual temperatures experienced by subtidal organisms. Here, we describe the benthic temperature climatology of 4 coastal locations along a ~1000 km latitudinal gradient in ocean temperature in Western Australia (WA), and compare temperature records from in situ loggers at 10 to 12 m depth with records from 2 independent satellite-derived SST datasets over 2 years. Satellite-derived SSTs were significantly correlated with in situ logger data at all locations, which demonstrate their overall ability to detect general patterns of ecological importance. However, SSTs were also significantly different from benthic water temperatures (usually 1 to 2°C higher), and they did not adequately detect ecologically important small-scale variability or provide reliable information on temperature extremes. Furthermore, rank orders of the study locations differed between the methodologies, especially in winter. We emphasize the need to carefully consider whether the accuracy and resolution of satellite-derived SSTs are appropriate for the specific ecological hypothesis being tested in nearshore subtidal habitats, and advocate the use of in situ loggers otherwise. We also highlight the suitability of the WA coastline for experimental work on the effects of temperature (and synergistic factors) on marine organisms.
KEY WORDS: Benthic climatology · Satellite-derived SST · Temperature gradient · Shallow water habitats
Resale or republication not permitted without written consent of the publisherMar Ecol Prog Ser 387: [27][28][29][30][31][32][33][34][35][36][37] 2009 ever, this measurement is derived from the top 'skin' of seawater (~0.01 mm thick) and may not be representative of seawater temperature further down in the water column ('bulk' temperature). The relationship between 'skin' and 'bulk' temperature is strongly influenced by sea state, weather conditions and local oceanography, and has been the focus of many ground-truthing studies (Barton & Pearce 2006. It is clear that, under certain conditions, SST values may be representative of water temperatures to depths of a few meters in the open ocean (Katsaros 2003). Such observations may have prompted the use of satellite-derived SSTs in shallow-water ecological studies. However, in shallow coastal benthic habitats, factors such as tides, waves, water clarity and the thermal properties of the substratum, may influence temperature profiles and possibly reduce the correspondence between SSTs and the temperatures experienced by organisms living near the bottom. Given the severity of likely impacts, there is an increasing need to understand how organisms would respond to the current rate of global change, including ocean warming, and such an understanding is only possible if coupled with accurate environmental data. Here, we compare temperatures measured in sit...