The Ludic Bestiary: Misogynistic Tropes of Female Monstrosity in Dungeons & Dragons

Abstract

This article introduces the concept of the ludic bestiary, a game mechanic that the authors argue produces abject bodies. Using the “hag” in Dungeons & Dragons as a case study, the authors demonstrate how the game’s bestiary, the Monster Manual, functions as a tool of patriarchal control by defining, categorizing, and classifying the body of the female other as evil, abject, and monstrous. Importantly, the ludic bestiary not only exists as a core rulebook in Dungeons & Dragons but has also been remediated as a narrative-heavy submenu in several digital games. The authors find that the figure of the monstrous woman persists in games because of the widespread distribution of the Monster Manual to young men in hobby communities, the cultural influence of Dungeons & Dragons, depictions of monstrosity that blend the erotic with the maternal, and the discursive categorization and objectification of the female body by ludic systems.

Chasing theDragon(Magazine): Gender Erasure Through Discourse inDragonMagazine, 1978–2005

“…This article expands existing research on topics related to analog gamer masculinity and interpretations of misogyny that exist in the tabletop role-playing world, while also noting discussions of discourses in TRPGs (Cover, 2014;Martin et al, 2015;Stang & Trammell, 2020;Trammell, 2018b). The sidelining of women discussed herein, I argue, was not historically done as a purposeful attempt to create or reinforce a circumstance of "no girls allowed."…”

Pivotal Play: Rethinking Meaningful Play in Games Through Death in Dungeons & Dragons

“…A review of contemporary D&D literature shows attention toward areas such as D&D's immersive experiences (Mizer, 2019;Wouters, Rogerson, & Hu, 2021), critical consideration of the game's present inclusivity (e.g., Cote, 2020, pp. 190-197;Jones, 2018;Jones & Pobuda, 2020;Stang & Trammell, 2019;Stokes, 2017;Trammell, 2014), and comprehensive historical documentation of the game (Peterson, 2012(Peterson, , 2018(Peterson, , 2020(Peterson, , 2021. Research has also covered D&D's rulesets and structures (Dashiell, 2017(Dashiell, , 2018, related media representations and modern resurgence (Chalk 2018;Sidhu & Carter, 2020a, 2020bStanton & Johnson, 2021), and influence of the game on digital successors (LaLone, 2019;Voorhees, Call, & Whitlock, 2012;Zagal & Deterding, 2018).…”

From Tabletop to Screen: Playing Dungeons and Dragons during COVID-19

“…Academic literature on the experiences of play in D&D are relatively sparse, with a significant body of the literature focusing on the content and contextual elements of D&D, such as representations of race and gender [13,14]. However, research examining the social aspects of play exist which support aspects of Fine's early work, including how D&D helps fulfill players' social needs [15], similar to how small guilds in MMORPGs such as World of Warcraft function as a platform to maintain social relationships between friends and family [16].…”