The Normalization of Bogota Social Housing Residents: Class Tensions in Third World Urban Peripheries

Abstract

Strangers with different economic needs come to live together in social housing projects, posing an organizational challenge. In most current Latin American cities, this tends to be in standardized complexes with small apartments in segregated peripheries. Many residents change from living in informal neighborhoods to a different type of urban citizenship based on partially subsidized home ownership, which they experience as social mobility. Others already live in the formal city and buy their apartments without a subsidy. How neighbors relate to each other, handle conflicts, and organize becomes a practical problem that worries governments, residents, and developers. This article analyzes tensions in social housing complexes in Bogotá, in relation to national regulations, architectural design, and residents' hopes and aspirations. Based on survey and ethnographic data, it claims that the rigid material and normative environment of social housing negatively affects neighborly relations, resulting in lack of trust, conflicts, and working against a sense of community. It shows that educational community programs serve as vehicles for "normalization" and atomization according to middle-class ideals of citizenship. Residents embrace the restrictions that suit their aspirations for social mobility and inclusion, yet negotiate others in the face of economic need.

Judicialización y política urbana: Ciudadanos, políticos y jueces en la suspensión de Transmilenio por la Séptima en Bogotá.

“…En esta investigación, nos parece más relevante poner nuestro foco de análisis en un proceso más amplio: el significativo aumento de la clase media en las últimas dos décadas en América Latina (Hurtado-Tarazona et al, 2020;Uribe & Ramírez, 2019), el aumento de su interés en temas de ciudad y planeación urbana (Nogueira, 2020), y el desarrollo de nuevos imaginarios que la motivan a buscar nuevas formas de incidencia en la política urbana latinoamericana (Fuentes & MacClure, 2020). Así, frente a las tradicionales conceptualizaciones de la política urbana en América Latina como un enfrentamiento entre elites desterritorializadas vs. poblaciones vulnerables que defienden su territorio, creemos necesario prestarle mayor atención a la movilización social, legal y de imaginarios de la emergente clase urbana latinoamericana.…”

Housing and Reincorporation Strategies in post-Conflict Colombia: Mismatch of micro-level visions and macro-scale approaches

“…This reflects Colombia's long-standing pursuit to expand homeownership through the construction of new homes, relying on the private market to provide cheaper housing options for the poor. With a growing housing deficit, in the last decades, national housing strategies have focused mainly on the development of large scale housing projects often located in peripheral areas with no access to infrastructure, services, public transportation, or livelihood opportunities thus further marginalising the poor (Acosta Restrepo & Henao Padilla, 2011;Hurtado-Tarazona et al, 2020). These mainstream initiatives are considered inadequate by ex-combatants as they neither recognise their specific situation, nor those of the housing and livelihood needs of poor rural families in Colombia more broadly (Ospina, 2020).…”