The Political Economy of Skill Formation in a Rentier State: The Case of Oman

Abstract

Context: Against a backdrop of dwindling oil resources and increasing unemployment rates, the government of Oman has set out to diversify its industry and establish a knowledge-based economy. In this context, forming a highly-skilled Omani workforce is considered to be of crucial importance. Yet, the national TVET system suffers from low social status, poor quality, and limited labour market connectivity. This paper offers an analysis of Oman's TVET system in the socio-economic and cultural context of a rentier state. Approach: We draw on the political economy of skills and socio-cultural approaches that understand TVET systems and the broader skills regimes in which they are embedded as part and expression of particular patterns of the social organisation of work. This helps to locate TVET systems' strengths and weaknesses in the context of their underlying social relations instead of considering them as mere dysfunctionalities at the systemic level. This paper draws on an unpublished study on TVET for industrialisation commissioned by an Omani line ministry in cooperation with an international organisation. For this study, the authors carried out a literature review, undertook two field trips to Oman in 2018 and 2019 and conducted forty semi-structured interviews with stakeholders from government, private companies, business associations, and TVET and higher education institutions. Findings: Our analysis highlights how skill formation in Oman is shaped by the socio-economic and cultural context of the Omani rentier state. First, the availability of cheap expatriate labour and Omanis' traditional preference for public sector jobs culminate in poor incentives for employing Omani nationals in the private sector. Second, reluctant employer attitudes towards national skill formation deepen quality issues in the TVET system, especially with regard to work-based training. This reinforces negative perceptions of the local workforce, which in turn contribute to biased employment patterns. Both social processes mutually reinforce each other, eventually preventing the emergence of strong national skill formation dynamics. Conclusions: While immediate structural change appears challenging, it is evident that reforms of the TVET system alone will not lead to its sustainable improvement. More research into how skill formation relates to Oman's specific socio-economic structures, how employment dynamics relate to educational credentials and how cultural traditions shape educational and work practices is needed.

Exploring Hikikomori-like idiom of distress a year into the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic in Oman: Factorial validity of the 25-item Hikikomori Questionnaire, prevalence and associated factors

“…The local economy and labour force were severely dented, and thus, options for aspirant job-seekers to secure meaningful employment became untenable in a country with an increasingly high number of job-seekers even prior to the onset of the pandemic [ 79 ]. There is also evidence to suggest that while the country ceased to accommodate much-needed employment in government sectors, emerging private sectors catering to the tourism and services industry are perceived to be a less attractive alternative for career aspirations of Omanis [ 80 ]. In a society where education, occupation and ‘isms and schisms’ are of great significance, some vulnerable young people who do not live up to societal expectations may be more vulnerable to developing symptoms of HLID.…”

Preparing the youth for the future of work through apprenticeship programme in Brunei

“…To reduce unemployment, the government has encouraged graduates to be more open to labour market changes and work trends by adopting a growth mentality (Mohamad, 2022). Since the 1980s, the rentier mentality has been a prevalent phenomenon in affluent oil nations; the problem originates from the idea that wealth accumulation promotes idleness, resulting in low workforce involvement and contributions to other national developments (Hertog, 2020;Langthaler et al, 2022). "rentier mentality" which results from a "break in the work-reward causal link where income is not related to work in a production circuit or to risk bearing but is a windfall gain related to choice and social situation" (Beblawi, 1990).…”

“…To reduce unemployment, the government has encouraged graduates to be more open to labour market changes and work trends by adopting a growth mentality (Mohamad, 2022). Since the 1980s, the rentier mentality has been a prevalent phenomenon in affluent oil nations; the problem originates from the idea that wealth accumulation promotes idleness, resulting in low workforce involvement and contributions to other national developments (Hertog, 2020; Langthaler et al. , 2022).…”

The Influence of Innovative Characteristics, Work Readiness, and Vocational Self-Concept on Employability of Vocational College Students

“…Employability of students from vocational colleges is crucial to meet the country's demand for 21st-century workers (Sa-Nguanmanasak et al, 2019). However, training and moulding vocational college students to effectively meet the demands of the global industrial market is one of the major challenges of technical and vocational education training (TVET) (Aktas et al, 2017;Langthaler et al, 2022). Several countries, including those in Southeast Asia, have attempted to restructure TVET to enhance vocational college students' employability (Campbell, 2016).…”