“…First, the literature does not support dichotomous eupnoea-and sigh-specialized neuron populations in the preBötC; rather, the consensus is that rhythmogenic neurons belong to the same, or extensively overlapping, preBötC network(s) (Lieske & Ramirez, 2006a, b;Lieske et al, 2000;Tryba et al, 2008;Viemari et al, 2013). However, if there are discrete eupnoea-and sigh-dedicated cell populations, then one population may be non-neural, consisting instead of astrocytes (Severs et al, 2023). Second, an inspiratory rhythmogenic role for I NaP is still a matter of considerable debate, with a branch of genetic knockout, and knockdown perturbations (da Silva et al, 2023) and pharmacological experiments (Del Negro, Morgado-Valle, et al, 2002;Del Negro et al, 2005;Pace et al, 2007a;Peña et al, 2004) unsupportive, and a parallel branch of modelling, pharmacology, and optogenetic experiments supportive (Ausborn et al, 2018;Koizumi & Smith, 2008;Phillips & Rubin, 2019;Yamanishi et al, 2018).…”